Tell your friends

TELL YOUR FRIENDS

POPULAR SEARCHES

List of Shows


The Young and the Restless - MESSAGE BOARDS

Soaps Boards :: The Young and the Restless Forum :: Am I Missing Something Here????

Please register and login to be able to post in this message board.

Am I Missing Something Here????

Started by Nubien at 2009/07/03 06:59PM
Latest post: 2009/07/03 08:45PM, Views: 317, Replies: 4
page:
#1   2009/07/03 06:59PM
Am I Missing Something Here????
Nubien
image

Somebody help me understand this....If Catherine switched babies when Jill gave birth to and gave Jill Phillip 3 to raise as her son, then where is the real Phillip 3 Jill's real son ?

#2   2009/07/03 07:10PM
Re: Am I Missing Something Here????
HOT PINK
image

The Phillip III Jill raised is, in fact, the real Phillip chancellor III. Either Katherine's memory of switching the babies was part of a dream she had while in a drunken stupor, or she didn't actually switch the babies. Hopefully, we'll find out the answer soon.

#3   2009/07/03 07:15PM
Re: Am I Missing Something Here????
clicquot1
image

Quote HOT PINK: The Phillip III Jill raised is, in fact, the real Phillip chancellor III. Either Katherine's memory of switching the babies was part of a dream she had while in a drunken stupor, or she didn't actually switch the babies. Hopefully, we'll find out the answer soon.

You are right HOTPINK only other explanation is they really WERE SWITCHED and she immediately felt remorse and switched them BACK. She does remember running across a field with a baby in her arms could that have PC3 and she was on the estate? Could she have confused the two "differnt babies as OREO has suggested? Her own bio daughter's birth and the birth of JILL's baby PHILLIP? Or did she see a baby switch in a drunken stupor in a MOVIE and just confuse it years later. So many great possibilities. YUMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM.

#4   2009/07/03 07:29PM
Re: Am I Missing Something Here????
HOT PINK
image

Quote clicquot1:
Quote HOT PINK: The Phillip III Jill raised is, in fact, the real Phillip chancellor III. Either Katherine's memory of switching the babies was part of a dream she had while in a drunken stupor, or she didn't actually switch the babies. Hopefully, we'll find out the answer soon.

You are right HOTPINK only other explanation is they really WERE SWITCHED and she immediately felt remorse and switched them BACK. She does remember running across a field with a baby in her arms could that have PC3 and she was on the estate? Could she have confused the two "differnt babies as OREO has suggested? Her own bio daughter's birth and the birth of JILL's baby PHILLIP? Or did she see a baby switch in a drunken stupor in a MOVIE and just confuse it years later. So many great possibilities. YUMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM.


I can't wait to see what the writers have come up with. Just hope it is a REALLY GOOD explanation.

#5   2009/07/03 08:45PM
Re: Am I Missing Something Here????
mpwifefl
image

I've been watching Y&R since the VERY beginning and have missed very few shows due to raising kids and the VCR/DVD-R inventions. NEVER do I remember any baby switching storylines where Kay was concerned. IF......and its a big IF.........they come up with this one, its an afterthought and, BTW, shame on the writers for coming up with such BOVINE SCATOLOGY!!!!!! I'm waiting for tne next show to fall ........to make PCIII gay. I have abbbbbbbbsolutely nothing against gay people but that's the SLEAZY way out of this story line. I do remember that about the time of the wreck, Philip and Nina were totally in love with one another and P3 shouldn't have had to run from ANYTHING.

Fix it writers.......if not, many of us are making you the laughing stock of the entire CBS soap writing teacm!!!!!!!!!

page:

Please register and login to be able to post in this message board.

« Go back to topic list