List of Shows


Tell your friends

TELL YOUR FRIENDS

General Hospital - MESSAGE BOARDS

Soaps Boards :: General Hospital Forum :: Report Card

Please register and login to be able to post in this message board.

Report Card

Started by joe2811 at 2008/08/22 01:58PM
Latest post: 2008/08/26 09:23PM, Views: 440, Replies: 40
« 1 2 3 page:
#21   2008/08/23 06:17PM
Re: Report Card
meowbowow
image

Quote tink55: I give the show a C+ for the day. I had a really hard time not wanting to FF through most of the show. I'm so over Robin not commiting to Patrick. Spinelli trying to win man points with Maxie. Lulu not facing her demons and wanting to run to Johnny. Skate bores me to tears. And Karpov just needs to go.


ITA. I yawned thru most of yesterday's eppy and actually most of the week. It was not very exciting to me.

#22   2008/08/23 06:31PM
Re: Report Card
joe2811
image

Quote meowbowow:
Quote tink55: I give the show a C+ for the day. I had a really hard time not wanting to FF through most of the show. I'm so over Robin not commiting to Patrick. Spinelli trying to win man points with Maxie. Lulu not facing her demons and wanting to run to Johnny. Skate bores me to tears. And Karpov just needs to go.


ITA. I yawned thru most of yesterday's eppy and actually most of the week. It was not very exciting to me.


Thanks Meow for posting and getting my thread to 3 pages...NoSoup will be proud and I will get my A+

I'm hoping this grading system will catch on and we'll all rate the show after we watch....I think back to school fever has caught on....either that or I have way too much time on my hands.

Modified 1 times(s), last time at: 2008/08/23 06:34PM
#23   2008/08/23 06:38PM
Re: Report Card
cardgirl
image

I am soooo sooo glad, Joe, that I came in this thread, but then, again, I usually go in any thread you start because I know it is an invitation for me to be snarky. But the reason that I am glad, is because I just came from the FYI thread where I said that all the crap with Nicadine was from tumor residue on Nic's brain. It makes feel so much better to know that I am not the only one who thought that.

As far as grading yesterday's show, well sadly, I will have to give it a big fat 0. I think it does not even deserve a letter grade.

I mean, really, the thought that Super Jason could just walk into a MENTAL HOSPITAL like it was the MOTEL6, and just take Looloo on a road trip to the PCPD to visit her boyfriend in a jail with NO BARS or metal detectors, or code of ethics which forbid the cop brother of the prisoner's girlfriend to have anything to do with said prisoner's case. Then there was that dress, that fugly dress, and whiney Robin saying no because Patty Cakes didn't propose in the way she wanted instead of being greatful that he is partially deaf and dosen't hear most of the nonsense that comes out of her mouth, which allows him to still want to be with her. And I don't want to even mention that nonsense with Nic and Bo peep because I have already convinced myself that it wasn't real....

I know I am ranting now, but there were just soooooo many things that were wrong with that show yesterday. I know it may seem that these are small details, but paying attention to little details sometimes make all the difference. And yes, a 0 may seem harsh, but I have been watching this show for a very very long time, and I know they can do better. Perhap we should suggest that Guza get a time out, and that he is no longer allowed to play with his Sonny and Jason action figures until he brings up his grade.

Modified 1 times(s), last time at: 2008/08/23 06:45PM
#24   2008/08/26 01:04PM
Re: Report Card
SlowAutumnWind
image

Nadine made a fool of herself
Piph laid down the law!
Johnny stood up to Big Papa
Nikolas and Claudia in the same room
Alexis may finally come to her senses
Laura and Lulu made me cry
Carly was actually kind
Spixie!
No Skate!
No Nikadene! ........ All good!


But......

Johnny didn't tell Nik the whole truth
Carjax made me want to fall asleep
Karpov made me gag,
No Liz! (They were doing sooo good!)

All in all a solid -A show.

#25   2008/08/26 06:33PM
Re: Report Card
joe2811
image

Quote SlowAutumnWind: Nadine made a fool of herself
Piph laid down the law!
Johnny stood up to Big Papa
Nikolas and Claudia in the same room
Alexis may finally come to her senses
Laura and Lulu made me cry
Carly was actually kind
Spixie!
No Skate!
No Nikadene! ........ All good!


But......

Johnny didn't tell Nik the whole truth
Carjax made me want to fall asleep
Karpov made me gag,
No Liz! (They were doing sooo good!)

All in all a solid -A show.


solid A- you say?

Only saw the second half today....I'm not sure I will agree because I thought I was bored...anybody care to grade today's show? I will post my grade after 10PM EST Soapnet.

#26   2008/08/26 06:41PM
Re: Report Card
meowbowow
image

Quote joe2811

Thanks Meow for posting and getting my thread to 3 pages...NoSoup will be proud and I will get my A+

I'm hoping this grading system will catch on and we'll all rate the show after we watch....I think back to school fever has caught on....either that or I have way too much time on my hands.


No problem Joe, glad to help!!

Too much time on yr hands hey. Is that a bad thing?

#27   2008/08/26 06:45PM
Re: Report Card
number1GHfan
image

Quote SlowAutumnWind: Nadine made a fool of herself
Piph laid down the law!
Johnny stood up to Big Papa
Nikolas and Claudia in the same room
Alexis may finally come to her senses
Laura and Lulu made me cry
Carly was actually kind
Spixie!
No Skate!
No Nikadene! ........ All good!


But......

Johnny didn't tell Nik the whole truth
Carjax made me want to fall asleep
Karpov made me gag,
No Liz! (They were doing sooo good!)

All in all a solid -A show.


ITA...A- quality... but I think that Nik asking Johnny what really happened was like a test for Nik to see if Johnny was willing to give up Lulu, and Johnny passed the test by not telling Nik that Lulu killed Logan....and I think that that proved to Nik that Johnny will do anything to protect Lulu, even go to jail for the rest of his life as long as Lulu is ok....

but since GH had:
NO Liason
No Jason
No Liz...she was only in the background
and the fact that they had Ric naked brought it from an A to an A-

#28   2008/08/26 06:46PM
Re: Report Card
meowbowow
image

Quote SlowAutumnWind: Nadine made a fool of herself
Piph laid down the law!
Johnny stood up to Big Papa
Nikolas and Claudia in the same room
Alexis may finally come to her senses
Laura and Lulu made me cry
Carly was actually kind
Spixie!
No Skate!
No Nikadene! ........ All good!


But......

Johnny didn't tell Nik the whole truth
Carjax made me want to fall asleep
Karpov made me gag,
No Liz! (They were doing sooo good!)

All in all a solid -A show.


Liz was on today, she was in surgery giving Nadine the "r u crazy" look and talking w/Matt about Spin.

Gosh I didn't even notice no Skate until u said it. It's always an amazing eppy when I don't have to watch that sickeningly boring couple!! IA, today was an A- where yesterday was an F it was soooooooooo incredibly boring. Another thing that made it an A- was not having to hear LuLu scream. What a great show!!

#29   2008/08/26 08:48PM
Re: Report Card
tink55
image

I'm going to give it a B for the day. The Laura/Lulu scenes were so good today, and shed a few tears I did. Carly wasn't too annoying for a change. Ephiphany back to running a tight ship! Glad to see Liz on screen but the not having much dialogue and having Nadine and Leyla have more lines than her just bugged me. And Maxie was alittle over the top. I'm still not sold on Lusam.

#30   2008/08/26 09:11PM
Re: Report Card
meowbowow
image

Quote tink55: I'm going to give it a B for the day. The Laura/Lulu scenes were so good today, and shed a few tears I did. Carly wasn't too annoying for a change. Ephiphany back to running a tight ship! Glad to see Liz on screen but the not having much dialogue and having Nadine and Leyla have more lines than her just bugged me. And Maxie was alittle over the top. I'm still not sold on Lusam.


Maxie and Nadine were both over the top and I'm sick of them in regards to Matt. I will never be sold on LuSam. I just can't get behind them b/c of the way they got together.

#31   2008/08/26 09:23PM
Re: Report Card
cardinalgirl
image

Grade: A-

For Laura being back on our screens again! This rates an A in spite of any other drawbacks IMO!

Other Pluses:
* Nick with Johnny...just wish Johnny had been honest with Nic, but holding out hope for down the road as he trusts Nic more.

* Nic's comment about Jerry to Alexis.....Loved it!

* Lulu and Laura together! Awesome!

* Lulu keeping Laura's secret and not telling Carly!

What stopped an A+ rating???

* NADINE....enough said!

« 1 2 3 page:

Please register and login to be able to post in this message board.

« Go back to topic list