List of Shows


Tell your friends

TELL YOUR FRIENDS

General Hospital - MESSAGE BOARDS

Soaps Boards :: General Hospital Forum :: Let's Talk About Lucky.

Please register and login to be able to post in this message board.

Let's Talk About Lucky.

Started by LadyCass at 2008/08/19 09:47PM
Latest post: 2008/08/27 06:24AM, Views: 1246, Replies: 139
« 5 6 7 8 9 10 page:
#91   2008/08/26 12:24PM
Re: Let's Talk About Lucky.
aerinha
image

Quote JaneDoe:
Quote meowbowow:
Quote Jolufreak08: I didnt literally say I would LOL I will go off on my brother if I feel he is beeing too overbearing.

Just because a brother a family doesnt give them a free pass to treat me like I am invaild person that cant any decission for myself.


LuLu can't make any decisions for herself right now w/the shape she's in, how could she?


Lulu has hallucinations sometimes, but she's still capable of making decisions. She explained to Lucky that she wanted to see Johnny because it might be her last chance if she were going to end up like her mom. She wanted to see the man she loves while she still had the chance. That seems pretty rational to me and for Lucky to deny her that was cruel IMO.

No, violence is not the answer, but maybe if Lulu had punched Lucky she could have knocked some sense into him.


Haven't most people said "I'd love to kill..." and not meant it? I say it. I also say I'd like to hit people and I don't. So let's let that rest.

Lucky never liked Johnny and made an issue of Lulu going crazy long before this. If he didn't want her dating a mobster he should site Lily's death and the Spencer's being hunted for 12 years, plus Sam getting shot. That's what you use. He used Laura's condition to try to manipulate her and it was wrong.

Now she's having issues, but when she's not hallucinating she's fine. She is mostly scared the hallucinations mean she'll end up a statue and it is causing her to panic. Lainey said it's her doubting her sanity that is the main issue. Lucky should be doing/saying things to show her she won't end up like that not trying to micromanage her.

If he was fine with Johnny b4 and all this happened I could see him blaming him as reasonable, but because he started in long before this I see it as more of the same. Maybe that makes me prejudiced, but to me Lucky needs to respect Lulu's feelings and let her see Johnny because she is an adult and made the adult decision to get treatment and shouldn't be punished for it.

#92   2008/08/26 12:31PM
Re: Let's Talk About Lucky.
meowbowow
image

Quote JaneDoe

Lulu has hallucinations sometimes, but she's still capable of making decisions. She explained to Lucky that she wanted to see Johnny because it might be her last chance if she were going to end up like her mom. She wanted to see the man she loves while she still had the chance. That seems pretty rational to me and for Lucky to deny her that was cruel IMO.

No, violence is not the answer, but maybe if Lulu had punched Lucky she could have knocked some sense into him.


LuLu is out of her mind half the time so how can she make her own decisions? It's not possible. Lucky denied her seeing Johnny b/c listening to him about covering up the murder was what got her in this condition in the first place.

How is punching anybody going to knock sense into them? It will only cause hard feelings and that's not needed here.

#93   2008/08/26 12:51PM
Re: Let's Talk About Lucky.
JaneDoe
image

Quote meowbowow:
Quote JaneDoe

Lulu has hallucinations sometimes, but she's still capable of making decisions. She explained to Lucky that she wanted to see Johnny because it might be her last chance if she were going to end up like her mom. She wanted to see the man she loves while she still had the chance. That seems pretty rational to me and for Lucky to deny her that was cruel IMO.

No, violence is not the answer, but maybe if Lulu had punched Lucky she could have knocked some sense into him.


LuLu is out of her mind half the time so how can she make her own decisions? It's not possible. Lucky denied her seeing Johnny b/c listening to him about covering up the murder was what got her in this condition in the first place.

How is punching anybody going to knock sense into them? It will only cause hard feelings and that's not needed here.


I was totally joking about the punching think as I believe the OP was too.

You cannot tell me Lulu was not in her right mind when she was scared she may never get to see Johnny again. She's afraid she may end up like her mom, but for now she's still having lucid moments and she just wanted to spend a few minutes with the man she loved while she still had the chance. Lucky did not deny her seeing Johnny because his advice about the cover up drove her insane, Lucky doesn't even know about that. He did it because he's on some power trip and thinks he knows what is best for his sister when he's never taken 2 seconds to actually listen to her.

#94   2008/08/26 11:42PM
Re: Let's Talk About Lucky.
shelrick
image

I am feeling completely bad for Lucky. I hear him talking to people and saying that he needs them. It seems that Lucky needs to talk, figure out what is going on with his sister, mother, brother, missing father. I feel like Lucky thinks he is about to spiral out of control and is asking for help and I don't see anyone listening to him.

#95   2008/08/27 06:24AM
Re: Let's Talk About Lucky.
frenchmocha83
image

A couple of things.

1. As much as I harp on Lucky for being a moron (and he still is), I DO understand where he's coming from. He is trying to help his sister. But, like Jason implied, Lucky doesn't listen to Lulu. I know that Lucky thinks that Johnny killed Logan, but so does Nik. And as much as Nik doesn't want Johnny with Lulu, he knows that Johnny being ok is part of Lulu's recovery. He doesn't like it, but he accepts the reality of it and is willing to tolerate it for the sake of his sister. One might ask, how does Nik know so much about Lulu. Answer--he talks to her and listens to what she says. He doesn't cut her off in the middle of her statement (even when it seems like she's rambling) and tell her that he knows better.

2. IMO Lucky's reation to Lulu has more to do with what he feels he should have done for his mother. He loves his dad, but he still has issues with the ways that Luke hurt Laura over the years. Lulu is almost like a do-over (for lack of a better phrase). He's gonna do for her what he didn't do for Laura.

3. I am very close with both of my brothers. I would do anything for them and vice versa. That being said, if I were somewhere and starting freaking out, my brothers would do exactly what Lucky did. But if I calmed down and wanted to stay and either one of them physically removed me, I would absolutely slap them silly. I may or may not apologize later. When Lulu started freaking out, Lucky was right to remove her from the situation. But when she calmed down and said she wanted to see Johnny because she might not have another chance, he should've gone back in with her and let her say her goodbye. He could've insisted on staying if he wanted, but to physically push her out when she was screaming to stay, not cool IMO.

« 5 6 7 8 9 10 page:

Please register and login to be able to post in this message board.

« Go back to topic list