Tell your friends

TELL YOUR FRIENDS

POPULAR SEARCHES

List of Shows


General Hospital - MESSAGE BOARDS

Soaps Boards :: General Hospital Forum :: Why

Please register and login to be able to post in this message board.

Why

Started by KierraG07 at 2009/11/05 11:49AM
Latest post: 2009/11/05 10:15PM, Views: 217, Replies: 5
page:
#1   2009/11/05 11:49AM
Why
KierraG07
image

Why is it that so many people are playing Claudia to be the victim in all this and Michael to be the bad guy. Let us not forget that she did kidnap his mother at gun point and was about to kidnap his newborn sister. Call me crazy but what Michael did was defend his mother.

I am sad to see Sarah Brown go as I didn't hate Claudia and really think she would have been a great character in the future. I still don't think that what Michael did was wrong. JMO

#2   2009/11/05 12:00PM
Re: Why
alikat
image

Quote KierraG07: Why is it that so many people are playing Claudia to be the victim in all this and Michael to be the bad guy. Let us not forget that she did kidnap his mother at gun point and was about to kidnap his newborn sister. Call me crazy but what Michael did was defend his mother.

I am sad to see Sarah Brown go as I didn't hate Claudia and really think she would have been a great character in the future. I still don't think that what Michael did was wrong. JMO


I agree...plus he lost a year of his life because she hired an incompetent nincompoop to carry out her orders for murder.

However, how his mobster adults are handling it...not so much good. But then, they above all others, know that the PCPD is most assured to screw it up so they must handle it themselves.

#3   2009/11/05 04:17PM
Re: Why
cherrycola
image

I don't think Michael is the bad guy. He instinctively responded to protect his mother. It was manslaughter in self defense, not murder.

Sonny though? He's the blame for all of it, and covering this up for Michael does Michael no favors.

#4   2009/11/05 05:19PM
Re: Why
meowbowow
image

Quote alikat:
Quote KierraG07: Why is it that so many people are playing Claudia to be the victim in all this and Michael to be the bad guy. Let us not forget that she did kidnap his mother at gun point and was about to kidnap his newborn sister. Call me crazy but what Michael did was defend his mother.

I am sad to see Sarah Brown go as I didn't hate Claudia and really think she would have been a great character in the future. I still don't think that what Michael did was wrong. JMO


I agree...plus he lost a year of his life because she hired an incompetent nincompoop to carry out her orders for murder.

However, how his mobster adults are handling it...not so much good. But then, they above all others, know that the PCPD is most assured to screw it up so they must handle it themselves.


What PCPD? Oh yeah, them!! LMAO at incompetent nincompoop, perfect description!! I was glad Michael got his revenge but at least HE didn't plan it, it just came to him. Love it!!

#5   2009/11/05 05:21PM
Re: Why
meowbowow
image

Quote cherrycola: I don't think Michael is the bad guy. He instinctively responded to protect his mother. It was manslaughter in self defense, not murder.

Sonny though? He's the blame for all of it, and covering this up for Michael does Michael no favors.


ITA!! This could just be the most stupidest cover-up of all b/c there was absolutely no reason for it. Claudia was going to run w/that baby and he stopped her the only way he could. She had a gun so he had no choice. WTG MICHAEL!!!!

#6   2009/11/05 10:15PM
Re: Why
Stacy1975
image

Quote meowbowow:
Quote cherrycola: I don't think Michael is the bad guy. He instinctively responded to protect his mother. It was manslaughter in self defense, not murder.

Sonny though? He's the blame for all of it, and covering this up for Michael does Michael no favors.


ITA!! This could just be the most stupidest cover-up of all b/c there was absolutely no reason for it. Claudia was going to run w/that baby and he stopped her the only way he could. She had a gun so he had no choice. WTG MICHAEL!!!!


Yeah, ITA. I think GH is missing the mark with this one. I think it's a super sloppy way to open up the plot for James Franco. I really think the writers could've done better than this. There was no reason for this cover up. Not even a flimsy soapy one.

page:

Please register and login to be able to post in this message board.

« Go back to topic list