Tell your friends

TELL YOUR FRIENDS

POPULAR SEARCHES

List of Shows


General Hospital - MESSAGE BOARDS

Soaps Boards :: General Hospital Forum :: A theory about Claudia . . .

Please register and login to be able to post in this message board.

A theory about Claudia . . .

Started by soapsurfer at 2009/11/05 08:00AM
Latest post: 2009/11/05 03:59PM, Views: 508, Replies: 24
1 2 » »| page:
#1   2009/11/05 08:00AM
A theory about Claudia . . .
soapsurfer
image

I posted this in another thread but I think it should have it's own category so I'm reposting it here. Please note this is just a theory and I'm just wondering if anyone else ever picked up on this under current . . .


Did anyone else have the feeling that Anthony had sexually abused Claudia? I know that's an ugly topic but that was always the vibe I got from their characters interaction. It would also explain alot about why she was so messed up. She turned all of that rage, frustration and helplessness into the persuit of power. It always seemed like the writers hinted at it but they never actually revealed it. Thoughts?

#2   2009/11/05 08:02AM
Re: A theory about Claudia . . .
soapsurfer
image

Someone in the other thread thought maybe Johnny was Claudia's son. So here is my answer to that.


I always had that feeling too! And if you go with that theory then you can see how helping Carly have her baby could cause her to snap because Anthony took Johnny from her and she never could tell her secret and so she snaps and decides to take this baby for herself. This would give Claudia so many more layers and help to explain her behaviors. JMHO though.

#3   2009/11/05 08:05AM
Re: A theory about Claudia . . .
soapsurfer
image

Another poster felt the time frame didn't match for Johnny to be Claudia's son and was not in favor of history being reworked. This is my answer to that post.

The writers left it very ambiguous about why she was sent away at 16 and they also never explained why Anthony would want to shoot Johnny as a little boy - remember Johnny told Lulu his mother was killed trying to save him - she jumped in front of the shot or something like that. Anthony could have easily lied to Johnny about Claudia's age. I don't know it just seems like there is a big piece of the storyline missing.


Now that is as far as this topic has gotten in the other thread. Please let me know your theories and opinions! Thanks!

#4   2009/11/05 08:15AM
Re: A theory about Claudia . . .
soapsurfer
image

I forgot to post also that 1. Anthony always called Claudia down - specifically a liar and a word that rymes with snore (had to add that to pass the sensors). 2. He wanted to kill Johnny when he was little - why would you want to kill the child of your angelic second wife - unless maybe he is a constant reminder of the evil things you did to your daughter maybe? 3. Claudia was sent away with no reason given. 4. Claudia was way too attached to Johnny for a sister. 5. Claudia hated her father but always saught his approval 6. Trevor always hinted at having some secret about Claudia that would ruin her relationship with Johnny

So this leads me to think that maybe this will all come out now that Claudia is dead and this will be what sends Johnny over the edge as predicted in upcoming spoilers.

#5   2009/11/05 08:22AM
Re: A theory about Claudia . . .
JaneDoe
image

Quote soapsurfer: I forgot to post also that 1. Anthony always called Claudia down - specifically a liar and a word that rymes with snore (had to add that to pass the sensors). 2. He wanted to kill Johnny when he was little - why would you want to kill the child of your angelic second wife - unless maybe he is a constant reminder of the evil things you did to your daughter maybe? 3. Claudia was sent away with no reason given. 4. Claudia was way too attached to Johnny for a sister. 5. Claudia hated her father but always saught his approval 6. Trevor always hinted at having some secret about Claudia that would ruin her relationship with Johnny

So this leads me to think that maybe this will all come out now that Claudia is dead and this will be what sends Johnny over the edge as predicted in upcoming spoilers.


As to why Anthony tried to kill Johnny, it was said that he was jealous of Maria's attention to Johnny instead of him. The night he tried to shoot Johnny, he had planned to take Maria out and she informed him that her and Johnny were going to see a show. He went into a rage and the rest is history.

It was also later explained that the reason he sent Claudia away was because he caught her having sex with Trevor.

Modified 1 times(s), last time at: 2009/11/05 08:23AM
#6   2009/11/05 08:35AM
Re: A theory about Claudia . . .
soapsurfer
image

Quote JaneDoe:
Quote soapsurfer: I forgot to post also that 1. Anthony always called Claudia down - specifically a liar and a word that rymes with snore (had to add that to pass the sensors). 2. He wanted to kill Johnny when he was little - why would you want to kill the child of your angelic second wife - unless maybe he is a constant reminder of the evil things you did to your daughter maybe? 3. Claudia was sent away with no reason given. 4. Claudia was way too attached to Johnny for a sister. 5. Claudia hated her father but always saught his approval 6. Trevor always hinted at having some secret about Claudia that would ruin her relationship with Johnny

So this leads me to think that maybe this will all come out now that Claudia is dead and this will be what sends Johnny over the edge as predicted in upcoming spoilers.


As to why Anthony tried to kill Johnny, it was said that he was jealous of Maria's attention to Johnny instead of him. The night he tried to shoot Johnny, he had planned to take Maria out and she informed him that her and Johnny were going to see a show. He went into a rage and the rest is history.

It was also later explained that the reason he sent Claudia away was because he caught her having sex with Trevor.


I never heard the Trevor detail! Thanks for that bit of info . . . but playing devil's advocate here for a minute it could be argued that why would a teenager be sexually involved with a man old enough to be her father - maybe she was already being victimized by her real father? I'm probably wrong but there is just so much that was never explained about Claudia - specifically her obsession with Johnny.

#7   2009/11/05 08:47AM
Re: A theory about Claudia . . .
littlebit74
image

Well when Trevor Lansing was on the show. I got the impression that Trevor was really Johnny's dad. Just a vibe I got. Kept it a secret to keep AZ from killing him. I think Johnny and Claudia are to close in age to mother and son IMO. Plus she was there the night AZ shot Johnny's mother. She protected him. I think the reason they are so close is they where all each other had, She put all her love in Johnny cause he was the only one who loved her. Her father didn't and there mothers where dead.

#8   2009/11/05 09:36AM
Re: A theory about Claudia . . .
sasusan014
image

I agree, there is something has not been told about Claudia. Anthony, hated her. Why?? Being a parent myself, I can not believe that you can hate your child so much. I would think if he was so angry with her that he could not deal with her at all, but, to say he would not mind if she was killed....I just can't accept that. Also, I would have thought that Jason would have made it look like the AZ's family killed her.

#9   2009/11/05 09:54AM
Re: A theory about Claudia . . .
missnatural01
image

I always got the impression that Claudia had been sexually abused/raped by Trevor. The conversations between them just made it seem like she was forced. Also, when she was testifying in Johnny's trial, it appeared she was speaking from experience.

#10   2009/11/05 09:56AM
Re: A theory about Claudia . . .
MoBetta
image

If i'm not mistake Claudia may have been raped by Ric's dad, and Anthony accused Claudia of seducing him. That's why he sent her away as a preteen or teen, and when she returned she had become cold, hard and bitter. She just wanted the love and respect of her father.

#11   2009/11/05 10:03AM
Re: A theory about Claudia . . .
JaneDoe
image

Quote MoBetta: If i'm not mistake Claudia may have been raped by Ric's dad, and Anthony accused Claudia of seducing him. That's why he sent her away as a preteen or teen, and when she returned she had become cold, hard and bitter. She just wanted the love and respect of her father.


Claudia admitted to seducing Trevor to get attention from her father. She had said that he only paid attention to Maria and Johnny, so she seduced Trevor to get his attention. Trevor was SICK for allowing her to do it, but I don't think he forced himself on her. I think the writers missed their opportunity to really explain WHY Claudia was the way she was, she was just vile with no excuse other than her daddy didn't love her.

#12   2009/11/05 10:09AM
Re: A theory about Claudia . . .
soapsurfer
image

Quote JaneDoe:
Quote MoBetta: If i'm not mistake Claudia may have been raped by Ric's dad, and Anthony accused Claudia of seducing him. That's why he sent her away as a preteen or teen, and when she returned she had become cold, hard and bitter. She just wanted the love and respect of her father.


Claudia admitted to seducing Trevor to get attention from her father. She had said that he only paid attention to Maria and Johnny, so she seduced Trevor to get his attention. Trevor was SICK for allowing her to do it, but I don't think he forced himself on her. I think the writers missed their opportunity to really explain WHY Claudia was the way she was, she was just vile with no excuse other than her daddy didn't love her.


Maybe we can get some back story on her with Johnny and Anthony now that she is gone. It isn't too late to still tell her story if it ties into Johnny's. JMHO.

#13   2009/11/05 10:13AM
Re: A theory about Claudia . . .
soapsurfer
image

Quote sasusan014: I agree, there is something has not been told about Claudia. Anthony, hated her. Why?? Being a parent myself, I can not believe that you can hate your child so much. I would think if he was so angry with her that he could not deal with her at all, but, to say he would not mind if she was killed....I just can't accept that. Also, I would have thought that Jason would have made it look like the AZ's family killed her.


He also sold her off to Sonny. That smacked of pimping her out to me. There are just some serious undertones that the writers should clear up.

#14   2009/11/05 10:14AM
Re: A theory about Claudia . . .
MoBetta
image

Quote soapsurfer:
Quote JaneDoe:
Quote MoBetta: If i'm not mistake Claudia may have been raped by Ric's dad, and Anthony accused Claudia of seducing him. That's why he sent her away as a preteen or teen, and when she returned she had become cold, hard and bitter. She just wanted the love and respect of her father.


Claudia admitted to seducing Trevor to get attention from her father. She had said that he only paid attention to Maria and Johnny, so she seduced Trevor to get his attention. Trevor was SICK for allowing her to do it, but I don't think he forced himself on her. I think the writers missed their opportunity to really explain WHY Claudia was the way she was, she was just vile with no excuse other than her daddy didn't love her.


Maybe we can get some back story on her with Johnny and Anthony now that she is gone. It isn't too late to still tell her story if it ties into Johnny's. JMHO.


I can only see that working if they bring her character back. I personally don't believe she's dead, they can use this storyline years down the road.

#15   2009/11/05 10:14AM
Re: A theory about Claudia . . .
clalvis
image

Quote JaneDoe:
Quote MoBetta: If i'm not mistake Claudia may have been raped by Ric's dad, and Anthony accused Claudia of seducing him. That's why he sent her away as a preteen or teen, and when she returned she had become cold, hard and bitter. She just wanted the love and respect of her father.


Claudia admitted to seducing Trevor to get attention from her father. She had said that he only paid attention to Maria and Johnny, so she seduced Trevor to get his attention. Trevor was SICK for allowing her to do it, but I don't think he forced himself on her. I think the writers missed their opportunity to really explain WHY Claudia was the way she was, she was just vile with no excuse other than her daddy didn't love her.



Claudia told Sonny that when she seduced Trevor to get back at her father, her father blamed her and that's why he sent her away and always called her a word that rhymes with mutt.

1 2 » »| page:

Please register and login to be able to post in this message board.

« Go back to topic list