|
|
Soaps Boards :: General Hospital Forum :: I Have A Question: Did Anyone Go WTF When Carly Told Jax...
Please register and login to be able to post in this message board.
meowbowow![]() |
Quote clalvis: Now that Carly has had the baby, all secrets that Jax hold that may or maynot pertain to Carly should be revealed. He must tell her about Dante and that he's Sonny's son,tht he is assisting Dante in taking down Sonny, otherwise there's no use in asking for understanding for withholding information. I wondered why Claudia didn't tell Carly about Dante being Sonny's son or at the MC for that matter. Olivia can't trust anyone about Dante b/c she never knows who might tell, even if she and Carly r good friends. Carly might feel it her obligation to tell Sonny and as we all know Carly CAN be a big mouth, lol. |
meowbowow![]() |
Quote lemone Do you mean Michael is not Jax's blood or not Sonny's? Because either way he is related to neither by blood. Right, he's AJ's and Sonny adopted him after he married Carly. AJ was a lousy father to Michael but Sonny is way worse and he DID trick AJ into signing over his parental rights. What else can we expect of Sonny?!! |
clalvis![]() |
Quote meowbowow: Quote clalvis: Now that Carly has had the baby, all secrets that Jax hold that may or maynot pertain to Carly should be revealed. He must tell her about Dante and that he's Sonny's son,tht he is assisting Dante in taking down Sonny, otherwise there's no use in asking for understanding for withholding information. I wondered why Claudia didn't tell Carly about Dante being Sonny's son or at the MC for that matter. Olivia can't trust anyone about Dante b/c she never knows who might tell, even if she and Carly r good friends. Carly might feel it her obligation to tell Sonny and as we all know Carly CAN be a big mouth, lol. I was wondering why CLAUDIA didn't tell CARLY about Dante while she held her hostage? |
meowbowow![]() |
Quote Bluedov6: Take this from the perspective of a mom who has her kids. Jax does not feel any instinctual love for Michael or Morgan because they are not his kids. He also has this on- going battle with their father sonny. Carly knows this and I was wondering why she would tell her husband about this incident when she knows he can possibly use this against sonny and michael('for the greater good') Carly is not on the Crucifix ... her son is by trusting in a man who put her son in danger by protecting his psycho brother ( Yes she should have withheld the truth to protect her son! OMG, ppl adopt kids all the time or marry someone w/children and love them just like they're their own and Jax IS that way w/Michael and Morgan. It's been shown for some time now!! The only reason he has an ongoing battle w/Sonny is b/c he lives a very dangerous life and he's seen the effects it's had on Michael. Sonny/Jason should have just let Michael TELL THE TRUTH FOR ONCE IN HIS LIFE. It would most likely be called Justifiable Homicide anyway b/c he was protecting his mother/sister. He didn't go there planning to kill her. IMO this is one stupid cover-up!! |
Bluedov6![]() |
I would agree with you if a kid was not involved! Sonny/jason don't have anything to do with his deliberately lying and/or with holding the truth to use that little boy as a bargaining chip. Even now, Jax still doesn't get it! He still is talking about sonny/ jason and what they did and how it would be for the 'greater good' but what he really means is 'throw Michael and Morgan away" that was youre old life with sonny Josselyn and me are your real family . |
meowbowow![]() |
Quote clalvis I was wondering why CLAUDIA didn't tell CARLY about Dante while she held her hostage? Good point!! Maybe b/c there was so much drama regarding Carly's delivery and Claudia running from certain death that she forgot about it. Once Claws got to the cabin everything happened so fast but who knows, lol. |
meowbowow![]() |
Quote Bluedov6: I would agree with you if a kid was not involved! Sonny/jason don't have anything to do with his deliberately lying and/or with holding the truth to use that little boy as a bargaining chip. Even now, Jax still doesn't get it! He still is talking about sonny/ jason and what they did and how it would be for the 'greater good' but what he really means is 'throw Michael and Morgan away" that was youre old life with sonny Josselyn and me are your real family . It is not about Carly/Jax or sonny or even about trust It is about her children and how he just disregarded them like trash! Im going to give you another hard truth! He never expected the boy to wake up! He figured he was just going to ride it out. Jax is not an evil person .... He is just a selfish hypocrite who really wanted carly the kids were just things that she had with sonny. I don't get where Jax is throwing away M&M just b/c Jocelyn is here now. Throughout Carly's pregnancy they all couldn't wait to be one big happy family and kept telling the boys how they were going to be great big brothers. M&M were just things huh? WOW, ok whatev!! |
soapsurfer![]() |
Quote meowbowow: Quote Bluedov6: I would agree with you if a kid was not involved! Sonny/jason don't have anything to do with his deliberately lying and/or with holding the truth to use that little boy as a bargaining chip. Even now, Jax still doesn't get it! He still is talking about sonny/ jason and what they did and how it would be for the 'greater good' but what he really means is 'throw Michael and Morgan away" that was youre old life with sonny Josselyn and me are your real family . It is not about Carly/Jax or sonny or even about trust It is about her children and how he just disregarded them like trash! Im going to give you another hard truth! He never expected the boy to wake up! He figured he was just going to ride it out. Jax is not an evil person .... He is just a selfish hypocrite who really wanted carly the kids were just things that she had with sonny. I don't get where Jax is throwing away M&M just b/c Jocelyn is here now. Throughout Carly's pregnancy they all couldn't wait to be one big happy family and kept telling the boys how they were going to be great big brothers. M&M were just things huh? WOW, ok whatev!! I'm with you meowbowow - Jax isn't throwing Michael and Morgan away. Carly is lashing out at Jax. Her telling Jax to leave is crazy - like Jax is going to leave her, Morgan and the baby alone with Michael in that house. Even Jason is worried that Michael just might be a wack job! |
keyssteph![]() |
Jax did know before her pregnancy and chose not to tell her. To protect his brother, not Carly. He knew Sonny would kill him if he knew. Jason told her he knew something but would wait until she had the baby to tell her, and he did just that. I don't want her with jax anyway. She belongs with Sonny and no one else. |
soapsurfer![]() |
Jerry was thought to be dead - remember the boat explosion in the harbor. As for Carly going back with Sonny - Please NO! But if she does she'll lose the baby - because you know there is no way in hell that Sonny will be raising Jax's daughter. Carly and Sonny need matching t-shirts - "We raised an axe murderer and all we got were these stupid t-shirts" |
Jordanna![]() |
Jax knew that Jerry was still alive. Jerry had left Jax a voice mail at his office telling him that he was okay. Also after he received the DVD outlining Jerry's part about the hit on Sonny he couldn't make up his mind whether or not to tell Carly. A few days later Olivia walked into his office and overheard the DVD being played and Jax listening to it. Jax told her he didn't know if he should tell Carly because it would destroy his marriage. Olivia told him he should destroy it and never tell Carly, which is basically what Jax wanted to hear. |
meowbowow![]() |
Quote soapsurfer I'm with you meowbowow - Jax isn't throwing Michael and Morgan away. Carly is lashing out at Jax. Her telling Jax to leave is crazy - like Jax is going to leave her, Morgan and the baby alone with Michael in that house. Even Jason is worried that Michael just might be a wack job! This Jax/Carly issue has nothing to do w/M&M IMO, only to do w/Jax keeping the secret from her. ITA her telling Jax to leave is crazy. He's not going to leave that new baby and well he shouldn't. Carly is just being ridiculous about all of this!! |
Bluedov6![]() |
I dont think Carly is concerned with the 'perfection' of Jax. This goes deeper than that. No one is perfect but Can u understand that you dont play with someones kids ? In a way and I hate to say this Carly got back what she did to Nicolas in spades ! |
Jmm1![]() |
Quote meowbowow: Quote soapsurfer I'm with you meowbowow - Jax isn't throwing Michael and Morgan away. Carly is lashing out at Jax. Her telling Jax to leave is crazy - like Jax is going to leave her, Morgan and the baby alone with Michael in that house. Even Jason is worried that Michael just might be a wack job! This Jax/Carly issue has nothing to do w/M&M IMO, only to do w/Jax keeping the secret from her. ITA her telling Jax to leave is crazy. He's not going to leave that new baby and well he shouldn't. Carly is just being ridiculous about all of this!! How is Carly being ridiculous about this. He lied by ommission about his brothers involvement...he kept a major secret from her that is concerning her child. I am sorry buit their is no way that she should just be like "oh it is okay...do not worry I understand that you allowed my son in a dangerous situation" I mean come on he kept it a secret for selfish reasons...sure after he dcided to not tell her she got pregnant and then he could not tell her but his original reason was pure selfishness |
Jmm1![]() |
Quote Jordanna: Jax knew that Jerry was still alive. Jerry had left Jax a voice mail at his office telling him that he was okay. Also after he received the DVD outlining Jerry's part about the hit on Sonny he couldn't make up his mind whether or not to tell Carly. A few days later Olivia walked into his office and overheard the DVD being played and Jax listening to it. Jax told her he didn't know if he should tell Carly because it would destroy his marriage. Olivia told him he should destroy it and never tell Carly, which is basically what Jax wanted to hear. yep that is how I remember it too.... |
Please register and login to be able to post in this message board.