Tell your friends

TELL YOUR FRIENDS

POPULAR SEARCHES

List of Shows


General Hospital - MESSAGE BOARDS

Soaps Boards :: General Hospital Forum :: I Have A Question: Did Anyone Go WTF When Carly Told Jax...

Please register and login to be able to post in this message board.

I Have A Question: Did Anyone Go WTF When Carly Told Jax...

Started by Donna L. Forrester at 2009/11/04 06:29PM
Latest post: 2009/11/09 12:33PM, Views: 1213, Replies: 61
« 1 2 3 4 5 » »| page:
#11   2009/11/05 01:17PM
Re: I Have A Question: Did Anyone Go WTF When Carly Told Jax...
Jmm1
image

Quote meowbowow:
Quote gimmemoreliason: I did. For a moment there..I wasn't sure Carly was going to tell Jax...but then she started yapping and I was shocked. That's putting alot of trust in Jax. I think it's safe, though. Jax loves Carly more than anything, and vice versa. They'll be ok. But it was a definite shocker that Carly, for once, told the truth to her husband right away and didn't lie about it or withheld it. I say good for Carly!!! She's tried so hard to be a good wife to Jax, and I think she's done really good. Jax got the baby we all wanted him to have, and Carly wanted him to have....I'm so happy for them both! I love these two as a couple. They are my favorite! (Since Liason isn't happening...for now...lol)


Isn't this a 1st where Carly has immediately told Jax the truth right away instead of having Jason or Sonny cover up the truth for her? I'm so happy that Jax finally has the baby he's wanted for so long, he deserves it. IMO Carly has grown up major since she and Jax first got married and it's about time!! He'll give up Jerry now and tell Carly everything and like he told Jason awhile back after Carly has the baby he can go after Jerry all he wants.


Hey girl hope all is well for you. I am a little confused on your post...are you saying that it was okay for Jax to lie and manipulate hsi family? I am sorry but I totally disagree with you on that one. Jax had chances to tell Carly the truth and he never did. He had a chance to tell Micheal too...but no he did not...He even had a chance to tell Jason...but he did not do that either.

He wanted to tell Carly the truth only because of guilt, not because he is a nice guy...Jax is a looser and he always will be...he thinks he is better than Sonny and that may be true to some extent, but he is not loyal...he does not know what that word means.

#12   2009/11/05 01:18PM
Re: I Have A Question: Did Anyone Go WTF When Carly Told Jax...
Bluedov6
image

YES! Why did she do that! The old carly would have never done that! she needs to realize that Jax hates sonny more than he loves her. In so much that he would tell her to sacrifice her son to the police. He has no affection for Michael other than a bargaining chip for him and sonny to fight over! I picked up on that earlier in his relationship with Carly before they got married!

#13   2009/11/05 01:23PM
Re: I Have A Question: Did Anyone Go WTF When Carly Told Jax...
Bluedov6
image

I was absolutely shocked when she told him about Michael I was like he is going to use this against sonny and michael. But this is stupid carly. If it were the old carly and he did that to her there would be crying but after she calmed down there would hell to pay !

#14   2009/11/05 01:23PM
Re: I Have A Question: Did Anyone Go WTF When Carly Told Jax...
Jmm1
image

Quote meowbowow:
Quote Jmm1

Linda, Jax knew about Jerry's involvement way before Carly was prego. He found out on their honeymoon and did not tell her because he did not trust that she would stay with him. Him keeping it a secret has nothing to do with her health but his selfishness


Jax isn't perfect and Carly has always known how much he loves his brother even if he is a bad boy. None of us know what we would do to protect a loved one.


I am sorry but it does not matter how much he loves his brother. He has known that Jerry was evil for years and always protected him. Jerry is no better than Sonny, yet Jax wants Sonny to burn in HE!! but lets Jerry walk away....come on...that is no hypricitical....


And yes I know that Jax told Jason he could go after him after Carly had the baby....but why not go to Jason before Carly was pregnant with the information that he had...I will tell you why...it is because he wanted Carly to himself and to protect his evil brother.....
And yes I do know what I would do to protect a loved one...it is easy tell the truth...it will set you free...

#15   2009/11/05 01:24PM
Re: I Have A Question: Did Anyone Go WTF When Carly Told Jax...
meowbowow
image

Quote Jmm1: Okay I am sorry but I need to vent right now. so please bear with me....as most of you know I totally dislike Jax, always have and always will...

Jax found out about Jerry's involvement way before Carly was pregnant. He should have been a man and told her the truth, but no he lied by ommision. And then when she got pregnant and it was a high risk one he decided that was the reason he never told her. I mean come on...did he know in advance she was going to have a high risk pregnancy..no I think not.

It just drives me crazy that he thinks he can justisify not telling her because she was pregnant. That is not the real reason, the real reason is he is a coward and was too scared she would have left him. That tells me he has no faith for Carly and how strong she is....


Jax is no saint but neither was Carly who constantly went to Sonny/Jason FOR MONTHS after they were married b4 she ever went to her own husband to fix things and get their advice which was WRONG. She also slept w/Jax and Sonny on the same night and Jax forgave her. He also forgave her for sleeping w/Sonny during the MCHC. How is Jax worse then Carly??

#16   2009/11/05 01:27PM
Re: I Have A Question: Did Anyone Go WTF When Carly Told Jax...
Jmm1
image

Quote meowbowow:
Quote Jmm1: Okay I am sorry but I need to vent right now. so please bear with me....as most of you know I totally dislike Jax, always have and always will...

Jax found out about Jerry's involvement way before Carly was pregnant. He should have been a man and told her the truth, but no he lied by ommision. And then when she got pregnant and it was a high risk one he decided that was the reason he never told her. I mean come on...did he know in advance she was going to have a high risk pregnancy..no I think not.

It just drives me crazy that he thinks he can justisify not telling her because she was pregnant. That is not the real reason, the real reason is he is a coward and was too scared she would have left him. That tells me he has no faith for Carly and how strong she is....


Jax is no saint but neither was Carly who constantly went to Sonny/Jason FOR MONTHS after they were married b4 she ever went to her own husband to fix things and get their advice which was WRONG. She also slept w/Jax and Sonny on the same night and Jax forgave her. He also forgave her for sleeping w/Sonny during the MCHC. How is Jax worse then Carly??


I never said that Jax was worse than Carly.....

#17   2009/11/05 01:27PM
Re: I Have A Question: Did Anyone Go WTF When Carly Told Jax...
meowbowow
image

Quote Jmm1

Hey girl hope all is well for you. I am a little confused on your post...are you saying that it was okay for Jax to lie and manipulate hsi family? I am sorry but I totally disagree with you on that one. Jax had chances to tell Carly the truth and he never did. He had a chance to tell Micheal too...but no he did not...He even had a chance to tell Jason...but he did not do that either.

He wanted to tell Carly the truth only because of guilt, not because he is a nice guy...Jax is a looser and he always will be...he thinks he is better than Sonny and that may be true to some extent, but he is not loyal...he does not know what that word means.


Hey I'm so-so, hope you're well. I'm not going to argue about Jax, all I'm saying is IMO he had legitimate reasons. He doesn't even have to tell her now but he's going to which will help put bad boy Jerry away for good. I don't think Jax is a loser at all, not everybody always make the best choices and he didn't.

#18   2009/11/05 01:28PM
Re: I Have A Question: Did Anyone Go WTF When Carly Told Jax...
Jmm1
image

Quote Bluedov6: I was absolutely shocked when she told him about Michael I was like he is going to use this against sonny and michael. But this is stupid carly. If it were the old carly and he did that to her there would be crying but after she calmed down there would hell to pay !


yeah if I were Carly I woud not have told him crap...he does not deserve to know anything about Micheal...he lost that right when he decided to lie on a daily basis to his wife and her children

#19   2009/11/05 02:12PM
Re: I Have A Question: Did Anyone Go WTF When Carly Told Jax...
luluspencer
image

Yes, but Carly is smart that's why she mention Jerry, all she has to do is talk to the police, about the Metro court, nine times out ten, Sonny save the tape. of Jerry talking with Claudia and Ian.

#20   2009/11/05 02:45PM
Re: I Have A Question: Did Anyone Go WTF When Carly Told Jax...
lemone
image

Well I think that Jax was in the right to say Carly made a mistake lying about Michael. Carly/Jason/Sonny have just sealed Michael's fate to be a mobster. No consequences for his actions, ever. Sonny/Jason/Carly are just all kinds of wrong...they worry about Michael going mob and yet they continue to enable him.

SO when Carly started crying I did not feel sorry for her at all because I was too busy thinking what an idiotic thing it was she just did.

#21   2009/11/05 03:00PM
Re: I Have A Question: Did Anyone Go WTF When Carly Told Jax...
tonyalynn
image

I agree!

#22   2009/11/05 03:02PM
Re: I Have A Question: Did Anyone Go WTF When Carly Told Jax...
bigtimesoapfan
image

Quote soapsurfer: In my opinion Jax was 100% going to tell Carly once she had that baby. Remember, Jason and Sam went to Jax and Jax told them as soon as Carly has the baby I will tell you everything, my brother can burn in hell. He also told Michael as soon as the baby came he would tell him and Carly eveything. Jax wanting Sonny out of the picture is not a bad thing in my book. Sonny is bad news and he has ruined Michael. Jax sees that. He loves Michael but I think he loves Morgan more - like a son and will do everything in his power to prevent Morgan from becoming twisted. As for Carly telling Jax - good. She needs her husband. Seeing your son kill a woman with an axe is something you need your husband to carry with you. Jax isn't the enemy - Sonny and his mob are but that's just my opinion.


ITA!! All excellent and valid points!! Awesome post!!

#23   2009/11/05 04:29PM
Re: I Have A Question: Did Anyone Go WTF When Carly Told Jax...
soapsurfer
image

There have been some posts that say Jax doesn't love Micahel or something along those lines - I think he does but my point is before the shooting when we still had little Michael - he and Jax had a great relationship. He would come running down the stairs and talk with Jax and they would play video games - the writers through that history out when they aged Michael and now we have Jax and him tollerating one another. I find that frustraiting. Also for the life of me I do not remember Jax finding out about Claudia and Jerry on his honeymoon. I remember Jax thinking Jerry was dead and I remember Claudia looking for those DVD's and then I remember Jax learning his brother was alive AND that he helped set up the hit when he received a DVD at his office in the Metro Court. If Jax kept Jerry's role quiet on the honeymoon maybe it was because he thought his brother was already dead - let sleeping dogs lie and all that.

Modified 1 times(s), last time at: 2009/11/05 04:41PM
#24   2009/11/05 04:36PM
Re: I Have A Question: Did Anyone Go WTF When Carly Told Jax...
lemone
image

Quote soapsurfer: There have been some posts that say Jax doesn't love Micahel or something along those lines - I think he does but my point is before the shooting when we still had little Michael - he and Jax had a great relationship. He would come running down the stairs and talk with Jax and they would play video games - the writers thru that history out when they aged Michael and now we have Jax and him tollerating. I find that frustraiting. Also for the life of me I do not remember Jax finding out about Claudia and Jerry on his honeymoon. I remember Jax thinking Jerry was dead and I remember Claudia looking for those DVD's and then I remember Jax learning his brother was alive AND that he helped set up the hit when he received a DVD at his office in the Metro Court. If Jax kept Jerry's role quiet on the honeymoon maybe it was because he thought his brother was already dead - let sleeping dogs lie and all that.


Yes I was under the impression that Jax did care for Michael and not just out of spite to Sonny. It seemed like he honestly cared about what was going to happen with Michael looking up to Sonny. I'm with Jax let's get Sonny behind bars.

Modified 1 times(s), last time at: 2009/11/05 04:36PM
#25   2009/11/05 04:45PM
Re: I Have A Question: Did Anyone Go WTF When Carly Told Jax...
meowbowow
image

Quote soapsurfer: There have been some posts that say Jax doesn't love Micahel or something along those lines - I think he does but my point is before the shooting when we still had little Michael - he and Jax had a great relationship. He would come running down the stairs and talk with Jax and they would play video games - the writers through that history out when they aged Michael and now we have Jax and him tollerating one another. I find that frustraiting. Also for the life of me I do not remember Jax finding out about Claudia and Jerry on his honeymoon. I remember Jax thinking Jerry was dead and I remember Claudia looking for those DVD's and then I remember Jax learning his brother was alive AND that he helped set up the hit when he received a DVD at his office in the Metro Court. If Jax kept Jerry's role quiet on the honeymoon maybe it was because he thought his brother was already dead - let sleeping dogs lie and all that.


I don't remember Jax lying on their honeymoon either. I thot Jerry was presumed dead then but I could be wrong. I think u have the events correct that happened. Maybe someone else can enlighten us!!

« 1 2 3 4 5 » »| page:

Please register and login to be able to post in this message board.

« Go back to topic list