Tell your friends

TELL YOUR FRIENDS

POPULAR SEARCHES

List of Shows


The Bold and the Beautiful - MESSAGE BOARDS

Soaps Boards :: The Bold and the Beautiful Forum :: Taylor and Brooke...what caused them to dislike one another

Please register and login to be able to post in this message board.

Taylor and Brooke...what caused them to dislike one another

Started by BetchaDidntKnow at 2009/11/12 07:21AM
Latest post: 2009/11/15 09:15AM, Views: 442, Replies: 15
1 2 » »| page:
#1   2009/11/12 07:21AM
Taylor and Brooke...what caused them to dislike one another
BetchaDidntKnow
image

I've noticed that we've all been aggressively supporting either Taylor or Brooke and wondered why, we, the viewers think these two women dislike one another so much? What caused the conflict? Why we support each one to within an nth of our lives.
I'll go first. I've disliked Brooke, since the day that she single handedly, wrenched Taylor's control and professional choice (doctor/client privileges)out of her hands. When Brooke, whined, threatened and bullied Taylor into telling Ridge about Caroline dying. If Taylor wouldn't do it then she'd do it herself. She took it upon herself to inject herself in business that had absolutely nothing to do with her. She listened in on a conversation that she knew was not meant for her ears and simply had to become involved. Most of us know how that went down. But what was the real kicker is that rather than allow Taylor to tell Ridge this devastating information alone, she stood there in that office and waited to offer Ridge support for his "emotional" breakdown. The breakdown didn't happen.
Okay, so that tells you, I've disliked Brooke from her first serious interactions with Taylor because of that one specific event.
Anyone else want to share, their why's?

Modified 1 times(s), last time at: 2009/11/12 07:36AM
#2   2009/11/12 11:30AM
Re: Taylor and Brooke...what caused them to dislike one another
bridge1
image

Unfortunately, these postings about Taylor VS Brooke brings out a lot of negativity...I will not be sharing my opinion on this subject.

Modified 1 times(s), last time at: 2009/11/12 11:32AM
#3   2009/11/12 12:54PM
Re: Taylor and Brooke...what caused them to dislike one another
silo
image

I think Taylor hates Brooke because of her interferring in her marriages with both Ridge and Nick, which I totally understand. Although, I don't think that her marriage to Nick would have ended, if Taylor had been a stronger person and stood up to Brooke.

Next, I've always prefered Brooke over Taylor, because for me, Brooke is much more interesting, has more personality than Taylor will ever have. Also for me, Brooke is the person on the show who has matured the most (even though she annoys me as hell, because she never knows what she wants).

Brooke has admitted her mistakes and has tried to do better. Taylor thinks she's perfect and it's just so not charming the way she blames Brooke for everything!!!

#4   2009/11/12 01:05PM
Re: Taylor and Brooke...what caused them to dislike one another
carolinagals
image

Actually, Taylor started it all when she went after Ridge when Caroline died. Caroline knew Ridge loved Brooke and wanted them to be together. However, Taylor told Brooke to stay away and let him heal, which Brooke did. Taylor, though. put herself into Ridge's life by making visits to his office and generally just chasing after him. To me, Taylor was the conniving one. I wondered why Brooke didn't kick her a**. Brooke was always the sweet one, while the two evil plotters, Taylor and Stephanie, were always trying to break up Ridge and Brooke. It took Ridge years to see what Taylor was really like.

#5   2009/11/12 02:24PM
Re: Taylor and Brooke...what caused them to dislike one another
Touched
image

I used to dislike Taylor for several reasons! The way she pounced on Ridge after Caroline died, while telling Brooke to keep her distance was one. I disliked her for the lie she perpetuated for ten years, all the while berating Brooke for her choices, and, even though I don't particularly care for Ridge, the way she treated him when he did the famous email boink! The whining, nearly every single day, and the fact that she would always blame Ridge for his wandering eye and his flirtatious personality! She even watched him seduce Brooke in Venice! Well, seducing involves more than just looking, it involve handplay and tongue action. All of which Taylor continually blamed Brooke for causing!

Then the actress left the screen for two and a half years! When she came back, she was so much better than before, and believe me, I dreaded her coming back! She has bad behavior, but she is more willing now to admit it than ever before!

What caused Taylor and Brooke to dislike one another? It's a dead heat between Stephanie and Ridge!

#6   2009/11/12 06:59PM
Re: Taylor and Brooke...what caused them to dislike one another
grandmarose
image

Touched, I love your post. When Caroline married Ridge, she encouraged him to maintain his friendship with Brooke because she was secure in his love and knew Brooke's friendship meant alot to Ridge. Taylor on the other hand was very insecure in his love because of the way she got him and tried to destroy that friendship. Taylor took every chance she could to say nasty things about Brooke, even to Nick when she first met him and found out he was in love with Brooke. She keep warning Nick about Brooke. She always needed to feel superior to Brooke.

#7   2009/11/12 07:19PM
Re: Taylor and Brooke...what caused them to dislike one another
BetchaDidntKnow
image

Quote grandmarose: Touched, I love your post. When Caroline married Ridge, she encouraged him to maintain his friendship with Brooke because she was secure in his love and knew Brooke's friendship meant alot to Ridge. Taylor on the other hand was very insecure in his love because of the way she got him and tried to destroy that friendship. Taylor took every chance she could to say nasty things about Brooke, even to Nick when she first met him and found out he was in love with Brooke. She keep warning Nick about Brooke. She always needed to feel superior to Brooke.


Was Taylor wrong in her warnings? What good did Brooke ever do for Nick? I think Brooke's behavior justified Taylor's warnings.

#8   2009/11/12 07:26PM
Re: Taylor and Brooke...what caused them to dislike one another
grandmarose
image

Taylor wanted Nick even when he was with Brooke. She wound up drunk in his bed. Somehow Taylor seems to want the men that have a connection with Brooke. Why would she ever allow herself to be involved with Nick when she knew how much he loved Brooke. She should have warned herself to stay away. She has had men who have adored her with no connection to Brooke and they don't seem to be good enough. Pierce, Dante, Omar all loved her, but I guess it makes a more tantalizing soap if you have the so called good girl vs the bad girl.

#9   2009/11/12 07:28PM
Re: Taylor and Brooke...what caused them to dislike one another
Ginger2
image

Quote BetchaDidntKnow:
Quote grandmarose: Touched, I love your post. When Caroline married Ridge, she encouraged him to maintain his friendship with Brooke because she was secure in his love and knew Brooke's friendship meant alot to Ridge. Taylor on the other hand was very insecure in his love because of the way she got him and tried to destroy that friendship. Taylor took every chance she could to say nasty things about Brooke, even to Nick when she first met him and found out he was in love with Brooke. She keep warning Nick about Brooke. She always needed to feel superior to Brooke.


Was Taylor wrong in her warnings? What good did Brooke ever do for Nick? I think Brooke's behavior justified Taylor's warnings.


Nick loved Brooke.......what Nick did or didn't do should have been no concern to Taylor. They weren't a couple then. Why did she even get involved? It was SO none of her business. That's just another reason I have nothing but disgust for Taylor. She sticks her nose in where it doesn't belong.

#10   2009/11/13 05:06AM
Re: Taylor and Brooke...what caused them to dislike one another
Touched
image

Quote BetchaDidntKnow:
Quote grandmarose: Touched, I love your post. When Caroline married Ridge, she encouraged him to maintain his friendship with Brooke because she was secure in his love and knew Brooke's friendship meant alot to Ridge. Taylor on the other hand was very insecure in his love because of the way she got him and tried to destroy that friendship. Taylor took every chance she could to say nasty things about Brooke, even to Nick when she first met him and found out he was in love with Brooke. She keep warning Nick about Brooke. She always needed to feel superior to Brooke.


Was Taylor wrong in her warnings? What good did Brooke ever do for Nick? I think Brooke's behavior justified Taylor's warnings.


Taylor did not have the balls to control her own husband and she should have! He was flirting with Brooke the entire time he was married to her and it was all Brooke's fault? Seems to me, if she had put her foot down, she would have been much happier or divorced...and I don't think she wanted to be divorced from Ridge. She let him do way too much crap, just to keep him!

#11   2009/11/13 07:52AM
Re: Taylor and Brooke...what caused them to dislike one another
BetchaDidntKnow
image

Quote grandmarose: Taylor wanted Nick even when he was with Brooke. She wound up drunk in his bed. Somehow Taylor seems to want the men that have a connection with Brooke. Why would she ever allow herself to be involved with Nick when she knew how much he loved Brooke. She should have warned herself to stay away. She has had men who have adored her with no connection to Brooke and they don't seem to be good enough. Pierce, Dante, Omar all loved her, but I guess it makes a more tantalizing soap if you have the so called good girl vs the bad girl.


I beg to differ that Taylor wanted Nick while with Brooke! She told the truth about Brooke's character. She essential stated that Brooke goes after men and then always winds up hurting them. She didn't lie! I recall that Nick made himself accessible to Taylor on many, many occasions. He began to pursue her and heck, she's a single woman, why couldn't she appreciate it and if she wanted return the affections. I think she was upfront with Nick that she thought it was a bad I idea and that he was the one who won her over. It's sad to say that in any romance that Taylor has because the guys want her, Brooke has to be tossed in. So, I guess if you think about the men Taylor has been with and Brooke is always mentioned as having been there first, what they heck does that say about Brooke?
Come on, Taylor was happily married when Pierce was on the show! Omar, twice held her captive while she was married! Dante, was a friend and unlike Brooke she didn't fool herself into thinking that she had to be with every man on the show. Why is it okay for Brooke to have Ridge and not Taylor? Doesn't she love him? Or does everyone think Brookie just loves Ridge more and will go to more drastic means to show her love? Please.

#12   2009/11/13 07:56AM
Re: Taylor and Brooke...what caused them to dislike one another
BetchaDidntKnow
image

Quote Ginger2:
Quote BetchaDidntKnow:
Quote grandmarose: Touched, I love your post. When Caroline married Ridge, she encouraged him to maintain his friendship with Brooke because she was secure in his love and knew Brooke's friendship meant alot to Ridge. Taylor on the other hand was very insecure in his love because of the way she got him and tried to destroy that friendship. Taylor took every chance she could to say nasty things about Brooke, even to Nick when she first met him and found out he was in love with Brooke. She keep warning Nick about Brooke. She always needed to feel superior to Brooke.


Was Taylor wrong in her warnings? What good did Brooke ever do for Nick? I think Brooke's behavior justified Taylor's warnings.


Nick loved Brooke.......what Nick did or didn't do should have been no concern to Taylor. They weren't a couple then. Why did she even get involved? It was SO none of her business. That's just another reason I have nothing but disgust for Taylor. She sticks her nose in where it doesn't belong.


That's exactly how I feel about Brooke, starting with Caroline, Taylor and then Macy! She can't help but to whine and keep her nose in everybody else's business. Which always results in problems for everyone else!

#13   2009/11/13 08:05AM
Re: Taylor and Brooke...what caused them to dislike one another
BetchaDidntKnow
image

Quote Touched:
Quote BetchaDidntKnow:
Quote grandmarose: Touched, I love your post. When Caroline married Ridge, she encouraged him to maintain his friendship with Brooke because she was secure in his love and knew Brooke's friendship meant alot to Ridge. Taylor on the other hand was very insecure in his love because of the way she got him and tried to destroy that friendship. Taylor took every chance she could to say nasty things about Brooke, even to Nick when she first met him and found out he was in love with Brooke. She keep warning Nick about Brooke. She always needed to feel superior to Brooke.


Was Taylor wrong in her warnings? What good did Brooke ever do for Nick? I think Brooke's behavior justified Taylor's warnings.


Taylor did not have the balls to control her own husband and she should have! He was flirting with Brooke the entire time he was married to her and it was all Brooke's fault? Seems to me, if she had put her foot down, she would have been much happier or divorced...and I don't think she wanted to be divorced from Ridge. She let him do way too much crap, just to keep him!


Yeah, Taylor could have done many things but she didn't. She let it play out and it did. But I don't think that it was Ridge doing the flirting and leading on.

For example, I distinctly recall Ridge dropping down to his underwear on more than one occasion in front of Brooke. Or dropping by Brooke's office for a family picnic. Oh yeah, and going to Brooke's house and looking through her bedroom window as she made love to someone else. Never happened.
Ridge finally realized that he couldn't be friendly to Brooke because she took it to mean that he wanted her or that he was flirting. I remember when Brooke finally realized that Ridge actually loved Taylor and only wanted to be with her. Like a big girl she told Taylor that she was sorry for all of the things that she had done to cause problems between Taylor and Ridge and wished them well.
Taylor was class and eventually got her way before those bad people sent her to soap opera death for the second time!

#14   2009/11/13 09:40AM
Re: Taylor and Brooke...what caused them to dislike one another
Kat232
image

Ridge is the biggest problem here. If he hadn't have led these 2 women on constantly regardless of which one he was with perhaps they wouldn't be such enemies now

Modified 1 times(s), last time at: 2009/11/13 09:41AM
#15   2009/11/14 08:24AM
Re: Taylor and Brooke...what caused them to dislike one another
Latricia
image

Quote Kat232: Ridge is the biggest problem here. If he hadn't have led these 2 women on constantly regardless of which one he was with perhaps they wouldn't be such enemies now


Exactly,people are always so quick to blame the women for everything and Ridge is the one who has the balls.

1 2 » »| page:

Please register and login to be able to post in this message board.

« Go back to topic list