Tell your friends

TELL YOUR FRIENDS

POPULAR SEARCHES

List of Shows


The Bold and the Beautiful - MESSAGE BOARDS

Soaps Boards :: The Bold and the Beautiful Forum :: Miss Perfect Brooke

Please register and login to be able to post in this message board.

Miss Perfect Brooke

Started by shademorgis at 2009/06/30 11:00PM
Latest post: 2009/07/04 10:44AM, Views: 2756, Replies: 101
« 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 » »| page:
#11   2009/07/01 04:42PM
Re: Miss Perfect Brooke
bonny girl
image

Quote GLfan85:
Quote bonny girl: When Brooke is with another woman's man she is in love and following her heart so of course its OK how could anyone question that.
Please let's get over the ancient history of Eric and Beth he obviously did decades ago and moved on to bed two of her daughters and quite a few others.If he had stayed with Beth would he have kept it zipped up? doubtful! and all theoritical that's not how the story has been written.
Brooke and Ridge have been supposedly married so many times but it has never worked out they should get the message the universe has been sending it is NOT meant to be .
Both of them should move on actually Brooke,Taylor and Ridge might like to try an online dating service and meet some one who has not dated/slept with any other member of their immediate families.


I disagree, I do think he would of KPIP. Beth would never have treated him as horrid and Stephanie has treated him. He wouldn't of had a reason to look else where for love, respect, understanding, kindness, and equality.


If the fictional Eric and Beth had stayed together living happily ever after the whole premise of this show would be lost instead of the Bold and Beautiful it would be the Boring and Bland. Oh wait it's that now

#12   2009/07/01 04:51PM
Re: Miss Perfect Brooke
michaelee
image

I think that Taylor indirectly fed Ridge the drugs which is as bad as directly giving it to him.

From a legal perspective, she is an enabler. If Ridge had died from an overdose, Taylor would definately be charged. She gave him the first pill and besides that Stephanie did make her aware of the fact that Ridge was observed taking her medication, so she is indirectly responsible for his addiction.

Once she became aware of Ridge taking her pills, she should have made an extra effort to keep the pills out of his reach, instead she left her purse conveniently lying around for him to help himself to more pills.

Yes, Ridge is an adult but he is also human and was incapacitated at the time. Simple, Ridge's history of heart problems should have raised Taylor's sense of awareness in this situation.

#13   2009/07/01 05:02PM
Re: Miss Perfect Brooke
Shore
image

Quote Nichole43119: Bottom line: They have both lied. They both have cheated. They both have manipulated. They are both nasty. They both don't have any morals. Neither is better than the other. Taylor due to an addiction accidently killed a woman. (she didn't lie. She begged her family to tell the truth and finally went against their wishes and told the police and stood trial) Brooke due to her addiction (needing to be the center of attention) slept with her daughter's husband.Taylor/Nick happy together. Brooke broke up that marriage. Nick/Bridget happy together. Brooke broke that marriage up. Bridget/Deacon happy together. Brooke broke up that marriage. And I don't buy the "to prove he was no good argument" She had a baby by the man. That means unprotected sex with your daughter's husband. Then she got pregnant by Nick (or so it was unsure who was the daddy at the time)

Brooke is just as self centered as Taylor is. She has manipulated and conspired to break up marriages just like Stephanie and Taylor have. So why should her marriage be safe? Don't you remember "Brooke's Bedroom" When Tridge was together and Brooke coming into Ridge's office 1/2 naked trying to seduce him?

It goes both ways. They are both wrong. Like who you like. But geesh realize that they are both just as wrong as the other.

I am so disgusted with the both of them. They both need to go to counseling

#14   2009/07/01 05:33PM
Re: Miss Perfect Brooke
grandmarose
image

Brooke has not been with every man on this show. She has not been with Dante, Clark, Massimo, Pierce, Hector, Adam Alexander, Shane, Rocco, Lt, Baker, Bill Spencer Jr. or Sr., Sly, Thomas, C.J. Blake Hayes, Zach Hamilton or his father, Whip, Owen, Giovanni, Jake, Oscar, Dylan, or Prince Omar. So it seems that she didn't have to have every man.

#15   2009/07/01 09:28PM
Re: Miss Perfect Brooke
brown1
image

Michaelee you have a very good point. She is an enabler. Grandmarose you go girl!!!!

#16   2009/07/02 01:38AM
Re: Miss Perfect Brooke
shademorgis
image

Okay so at last count Taylor had slept with her daughters ex-boyfriend Rick, not good. But Brooke slept with her daughters husband, Deacon and became pregnant. And if that wasn't bad enough, she slept with her daughters SECOND husband Nick. I don't care what her logic was-sleeping with your daughters husbands-ex or not is plain gross. That to me is why Brooke is beneath Taylor, even though Taylor should have steered clear of Rick.

#17   2009/07/02 08:50AM
Re: Miss Perfect Brooke
brown1
image

they've both slept with everyone. When someone starts manipulating your emotions, along with his mother that is when its over the top. Manipulations are much more damaging to your spirit.

#18   2009/07/03 12:40PM
Re: Miss Perfect Brooke
shademorgis
image

Manipulating peoples emotions is wrong, especially Stephanie manipulating Ridges concerning Brooke. But Ridge is an adult, he does not HAVE to listen to his mother OR Taylor. BUT sleeping with your own childs ex and getting pregnant by your daughters husband while your daughter is still married to him is about as low as you can go. Sorry, but thats worse then anything Taylor has EVER done. And Taylor might have been drinking but I do not think for one second that she had malicious aforethought in ACCIDENTALLY killing Darla. Brooke WAS scheming when she slept with Deacon. In her mind she did it to try to prove to her daughter Bridgette that Deacon was no good. EXCUSE ME! What mother sleeps with her daughters husband to prove to that daughter that the husband isn't any good?!?! And Taylor needs counseling? GMAB

#19   2009/07/03 12:54PM
Re: Miss Perfect Brooke
brown1
image

Shademorgis usually when people are being manipulated they dont have a clue. Therefore the name manipulation. They,ve all done bad things,but the whole idea of using her grown kids and death as an excuse to be together is really disgusting. Why would you want something so disgustingly weak and pathetic rising out of misery. Taylor needs someone strong and Ridge is definitely not the one. Ridge and Brooks relationship is more interesting and passionate because of the strength of Brook. Just a difference in character,nothing else.

#20   2009/07/04 06:02AM
Re: Miss Perfect Brooke
Hot for Nick
image

It is simple. Brooke owns up to her short comings whereas Stephanie and Taylor act like they do not have any. I mean Taylor killed someone because she was driving drunk and Stephanie has forgotten all about that.
Stephanie lied to Eric for years about Ridge and their daughter Angela, but we are not suppose to remember that. She is a two-faced hipocrite.

#21   2009/07/04 08:05AM
Re: Miss Perfect Brooke
Touched
image

Quote shademorgis: Okay so at last count Taylor had slept with her daughters ex-boyfriend Rick, not good. But Brooke slept with her daughters husband, Deacon and became pregnant. And if that wasn't bad enough, she slept with her daughters SECOND husband Nick. I don't care what her logic was-sleeping with your daughters husbands-ex or not is plain gross. That to me is why Brooke is beneath Taylor, even though Taylor should have steered clear of Rick.


Nick was an ex when Brooke slept with him, but you know what, she slept with him first! So what does that make Bridget, who slept with her mother's husband and became pregnant, even though Dante turned out to be the father?

So far, Deacon, an absent father, is the legal father of Hope! You ever wonder why he doesn't fight for Hope like he did for Little D! He's even willing to give up parental rights to her! Make's you wonder what he knows!

Taylor tossed Jack away, which to me, is just wrong! You don't toss your children away because you can't "bond" with them! If that were the case, there would be many more children out on the streets, because parents couldn't bond or deal with their children! She has made no effort to get Jack back! You think she would since she lost Phoebe! Instead, she concentrated all her effort in getting a man back, who obviously loves her, second best!

Tell me how she's a way better person!

#22   2009/07/04 10:28AM
Re: Miss Perfect Brooke
pms24-7
image

Quote GLfan85:
Quote shademorgis: For the life of me I cannot understand why Brooke can be with every man on this show-even other womens husbands and boyfriends and do no wrong. But if Stephanie or Taylor do the same thing then damn them to hell by god! I just do not see what is so grand about Brooke or Donna. Katie is nicer but still questionable after going after her neices husband. I am trying to understand this mindset, I just can't.


Brooke (who I much prefer over Taylor any day) is NOT and I will repeat this for those who just don't get it, IS NOT perfect. She has made some VERY stupid mistakes! Her first was trusting Taylor!!! I have blasted Brooke for her cheating ways, especially when it came to Deacon. Allbeit, Bridgett wasn't exactly a grown woman when she married a much older Deacon. (what is it with her and her daddy loves anyway?) while Brooke was very wrong for having an afair with her daughters husband, she was correct in the fact that he really didn't love Bridgett, which was what Brooke was trying to prove in the first place. But that gets forgotten, only thing Brooke haters want to remember is that she slept with her daughters husband!

But please people, lets not forget, Taylor is just as guilty as Brooke is in many ways! She lied, cheated, manipulated, and used her kids to get Ridge from Brooke. AND she is more responsible for the death of a young woman, a child's mother, than Rick ever will be of Phoebe! Now she's lowered her self to giving perscription drugs to a man she so desperately wants back who isn't in love with her but is very much in love with Brooke and always has been. And lets not forget, Taylor has been with every Tom, Dick and Harry on this show as well, more so than Brooke!


hahahaha...thumbs up ...lol

#23   2009/07/04 10:44AM
Re: Miss Perfect Brooke
vicc
image

I don't remember the SL suggesting that Brooke was scheming to prove Deacon as no good when she had sex with him.

I remember Deacon (being the dog that he was) continued to pursue Brooke who finally gave in to the desire (disgusting as it was). It was unfortunate that she got pregnant in the act. Brooke knew it was a mistake.

It is ridiculous to try to say Taylor is any better than Brooke. Taylor has been underhanded from the beginning interjecting herself into Brooke's life when she was supposed to be professionally counseling Ridge.
The worst thing that Taylor did IMO was to cover up killing Darla (even though it was an accident) and then get involved with her husband!

Taylor has been at least as low as Brooke--more than that she has been a BIG hyprocrite!!

#24   2009/07/04 05:03PM
Re: Miss Perfect Brooke
shademorgis
image

Now you all can see why I titled this topic Miss perfect Brooke. No matter what she has done there is always an excuse for her. The same does not seem to apply to Taylor or Stephanie though.

#25   2009/07/04 06:56PM
Re: Miss Perfect Brooke
vicc
image

Actually NO--I do not see why you chose the title
"Miss Perfect Brooke"...

I don't think Brooke is perfect as most seem to think
(including Brooke)...

To Brooke's credit--she doesn't seem to make excuses to think she is perfect...and unlike Taylor and Stephanie...Brooke doesn't see herself as a moral example...

Maybe you should have titled the post "Miss Perfect Taylor and Miss Perfect Stephanie" ...
you seem to need to excuse them.

Modified 1 times(s), last time at: 2009/07/04 06:59PM
« 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 » »| page:

Please register and login to be able to post in this message board.

« Go back to topic list