Tell your friends

TELL YOUR FRIENDS

POPULAR SEARCHES

Soaps.com - MESSAGE BOARDS

Soaps Boards :: Birthers

Please register and login to be able to post in this message board.

CLOSED: Birthers

Started by cats meow at 2009/06/12 11:39AM
Latest post: 2009/06/16 01:18AM, Views: 1055, Replies: 86
« 1 2 3 4 5 6 » »| page:
#11   2009/06/12 04:12PM
Re: Birthers
sarahconnor
image

Quote alwaysEJ: Regarding McCain's birth -

he was born to two American citizens, so it doesn't matter where he was born.

The reason Obama had to have been born on U.S. soil to be a naturalized citizen is b/c his father was not a U.S. citizen.

And lovesit, I agree, I didn't really want McCain anymore than I wanted Obama. Here's to 2012.


It does matter. Citizenship laws vary from country to country and McCain could easily have dual citizenship regardless of where his parents are from. what doesn't matter is that none of this is really under dispute anymore.

#12   2009/06/13 09:25AM
Re: Birthers
cats meow
image

sarahconnor, if i am repeating myself, sorry, may i just say there are a few posters that rock, and you are one of them

#13   2009/06/13 01:55PM
Re: Birthers
lovesit
image

Quote sarahconnor:
Quote lovesit:
Quote cats meow: the thing is, he did, but the birthers do not want to acknowledge that, you know what i like about you lovesit? you are always willing to see both sides of an issue, i hope i am that way too


I try to see all sides, but sometimes it is hard! There is so much extra work involved...you have to use multiple sources, go with your own opinions and try to forget others'...but thanks!
I had heard he did produce one, and the argument was that it was easy to fake one? Is that right? I don't remember the Repubs argument. I can see both sides here. Yes, it IS easy to forge a borth certificate...I have done so myself for reasons I will not disclose, but they produced one that has been accepted for Obama's whole USA life. Why was it not in question before?
I am no fan of Obama (nor was I of Bush) so I really feel that his citizenship should be the last worry on people's mind about him. To try and stay on topic, I feel he values other citizens of other nations as valuable as our own.
Now before you go and say no life is more valuable than another, I am simply stating that an American president should choose American citizens as his priority, and so far I don't see that (He obviously wants a lot of unhappy grumpy citizens, b/c he is trying to pass his cigerette bill as we speak). With him going around telling other nations they are just as good as us, and have the right to blow up other nations...IDK. I am definately not worried about his citizenship right now. I am worried my family will be shipped off again for a war with Iran now.


ok since we want to go political here it comes. please don't take anything i say to be mean..they are just my thoughts - my opinions. (some facts thrown in)

Obama has provided his birth certificate and courts have thrown out lawsuits which claimed he wasn’t a US citizen as frivolous.

msgboard.snopes.com/politics/graphics/birth.jpg

As for the statement about his grandmother, I’ve heard reports of that but they’re all from right-wing nutjob websites and given the fact he has a valid US birth certificate that would seem to be evidence enough that he’s a US citizen.

Some people tried to do the same to McCain at the time since he was born in Panama however it never gained the sort of traction which is rampant within the right-wing conspiracy circle. For example if you check the political section of Snopes – a non partisan website – almost every single rumor slamming a politician or political group is targeted against the left and almost always is false. Obama is the president and citing web rumors from biased and non-reliable sources isn’t going to change that fact.

Not going to go into the cigarette bill since I have no idea what that is. elaborate if you would like. As for the part about “telling other nations they are just as good as us” I’d have to see the direct quote of him saying this however since the US is a conglomerate of immigrants from every other nation on the planet such a statement would not be “out there” at all. In my opinion if you want to claim to be #1 you better back it up with facts. We’re not #1 in life expectancy, literacy, employment, etc. We are #1 in military spending, debt, prison population, etc.

As for anyone's family being shipped off to war with Iran – chances are less under Obama than it would’ve been under “Bomb Bomb Bomb Iran” McCain.



I don't know if you're debating me or just elaborating, but I'll try anyhow.
Bold #1: I was simply doing just that, citing internet rumors that I flat out said I never investigated, I just heard through the grape vine. Never did I try to persuade anyone of their validity. I also wrote where he presented one before, so why should it be in question now?
Bold #2: You should know about this, b/c it is your beloved president who is trying to come into your home and run how you live. I am no smoker, and hate when I have to be in the same environment as one, but I respect their right to do so. It is up to me, not the president/gov, to find another room. So I advise you to investigate this bill, b/c his next goal is "fat" people, according to a clip I have heard. (Some clips you don't need to know if they're not used in their entirety, they are self explanatory)
Bold #3: he stated we do not have the authority to tell people what to do with their nuclear devices...if you agree with him on that...IDK what to say. If you have a child, and they are playing with another child who is putting you child in danger, do you not have the right to tell that other child to stop? I believe you do. Personally, I feel we, along with every other nation besides them, have the right to say how they use their nuclear devices. We have all seen how they value human life and their disregard for stronger nations, like us. Why do we not have the right to protect ourselves from their nuclear bomb that can now almost reach Alaska??? If you do not believe me or EJ on this one, youtube it I guess.
Last Bold: IDK if you are disagreeing that we are number 1, but all I have to say is a quote from Tony Blair, when asked why he still believes in America "There are only two forces who have ever offered to die for you, Jesus Christ and the American soldier."
If that quote does not sway you, fine. Hows this - what other country has as many people as us trying to get in versus out? All the little facts are pointless for me about number one, overall, I believe we ARE number one. Our strength as a whole tells me that, not our deficit, not our hopeless government (left AND especially right), nor our death rate, survival rate, or any other statistic. Not for me, anyways. Just my two simple little reasons.

Also, please don't think there are only right wing nut jobs out there making these rumors up. There are plenty of left wing nuts, too. Don't leave anyone out. I am a conservative independent, and look at Dem and Repub web sites all day. Neither tells the whole truth, EVER.

#14   2009/06/13 03:08PM
Re: Birthers
grits1976
image

When I heard the first breath of that rumor, I found that it could be plausible. Upon further investigation I found that according to US law even if he wasn't born here in one of the 50 states, his mother held US citizenship and lived here 7 consecutive years before his birth so unless he has renounced this he is a citizen of the US, therefore eligible to run for pres..
While I don't think the Obama has the best interests of the country at heart I have to respect that he's the Pres.. I just have to hope that the American people come to that conclusion in 2012.

#15   2009/06/13 06:38PM
Re: Birthers
sarahconnor
image

Quote lovesit:
Quote sarahconnor:
Quote lovesit:
Quote cats meow: the thing is, he did, but the birthers do not want to acknowledge that, you know what i like about you lovesit? you are always willing to see both sides of an issue, i hope i am that way too


I try to see all sides, but sometimes it is hard! There is so much extra work involved...you have to use multiple sources, go with your own opinions and try to forget others'...but thanks!
I had heard he did produce one, and the argument was that it was easy to fake one? Is that right? I don't remember the Repubs argument. I can see both sides here. Yes, it IS easy to forge a borth certificate...I have done so myself for reasons I will not disclose, but they produced one that has been accepted for Obama's whole USA life. Why was it not in question before?
I am no fan of Obama (nor was I of Bush) so I really feel that his citizenship should be the last worry on people's mind about him. To try and stay on topic, I feel he values other citizens of other nations as valuable as our own.
Now before you go and say no life is more valuable than another, I am simply stating that an American president should choose American citizens as his priority, and so far I don't see that (He obviously wants a lot of unhappy grumpy citizens, b/c he is trying to pass his cigerette bill as we speak). With him going around telling other nations they are just as good as us, and have the right to blow up other nations...IDK. I am definately not worried about his citizenship right now. I am worried my family will be shipped off again for a war with Iran now.


ok since we want to go political here it comes. please don't take anything i say to be mean..they are just my thoughts - my opinions. (some facts thrown in)

Obama has provided his birth certificate and courts have thrown out lawsuits which claimed he wasn’t a US citizen as frivolous.

msgboard.snopes.com/politics/graphics/birth.jpg

As for the statement about his grandmother, I’ve heard reports of that but they’re all from right-wing nutjob websites and given the fact he has a valid US birth certificate that would seem to be evidence enough that he’s a US citizen.

Some people tried to do the same to McCain at the time since he was born in Panama however it never gained the sort of traction which is rampant within the right-wing conspiracy circle. For example if you check the political section of Snopes – a non partisan website – almost every single rumor slamming a politician or political group is targeted against the left and almost always is false. Obama is the president and citing web rumors from biased and non-reliable sources isn’t going to change that fact.

Not going to go into the cigarette bill since I have no idea what that is. elaborate if you would like. As for the part about “telling other nations they are just as good as us” I’d have to see the direct quote of him saying this however since the US is a conglomerate of immigrants from every other nation on the planet such a statement would not be “out there” at all. In my opinion if you want to claim to be #1 you better back it up with facts. We’re not #1 in life expectancy, literacy, employment, etc. We are #1 in military spending, debt, prison population, etc.

As for anyone's family being shipped off to war with Iran – chances are less under Obama than it would’ve been under “Bomb Bomb Bomb Iran” McCain.



I don't know if you're debating me or just elaborating, but I'll try anyhow.
Bold #1: I was simply doing just that, citing internet rumors that I flat out said I never investigated, I just heard through the grape vine. Never did I try to persuade anyone of their validity. I also wrote where he presented one before, so why should it be in question now?

Bold #2: You should know about this, b/c it is your beloved president who is trying to come into your home and run how you live. I am no smoker, and hate when I have to be in the same environment as one, but I respect their right to do so. It is up to me, not the president/gov, to find another room. So I advise you to investigate this bill, b/c his next goal is "fat" people, according to a clip I have heard. (Some clips you don't need to know if they're not used in their entirety, they are self explanatory)

Bold #3: he stated we do not have the authority to tell people what to do with their nuclear devices...if you agree with him on that...IDK what to say. If you have a child, and they are playing with another child who is putting you child in danger, do you not have the right to tell that other child to stop? I believe you do. Personally, I feel we, along with every other nation besides them, have the right to say how they use their nuclear devices. We have all seen how they value human life and their disregard for stronger nations, like us. Why do we not have the right to protect ourselves from their nuclear bomb that can now almost reach Alaska??? If you do not believe me or EJ on this one, youtube it I guess.

Last Bold: IDK if you are disagreeing that we are number 1, but all I have to say is a quote from Tony Blair, when asked why he still believes in America "There are only two forces who have ever offered to die for you, Jesus Christ and the American soldier."

If that quote does not sway you, fine. Hows this - what other country has as many people as us trying to get in versus out? All the little facts are pointless for me about number one, overall, I believe we ARE number one. Our strength as a whole tells me that, not our deficit, not our hopeless government (left AND especially right), nor our death rate, survival rate, or any other statistic. Not for me, anyways. Just my two simple little reasons.

Also, please don't think there are only right wing nut jobs out there making these rumors up. There are plenty of left wing nuts, too. Don't leave anyone out. I am a conservative independent, and look at Dem and Repub web sites all day. Neither tells the whole truth, EVER.


I was elaborating for the most part but I’d be more than happy to take part in a discussion.

I am guessing we agree on one part. why should obama’s birth certificate be in question at this point? It should not. my point entirely. Moving along.

BOLDED SECTION 1 ::

Careful. Do not presume to tell me what I should or should not know b/c you are taking things personal with such a statement. I bet I could find some things you should know that you don’t. no one is perfect here. so let’s say we don’t go there or maybe word it better next time? I asked you to elaborate - instead I did my own research.

Anyway I just checked the new bill and see nothing radical about it. It specifies no more “light” cigarettes or candy-flavored smokes, bigger warning labels, and fewer ads featuring young smokers. Wow crazy stuff eh?

BOLDED SECTION 2 ::

If you believe the US has the authority to tell other nations what to do, where do you believe that authority comes from? Does it come from the UN? From God? Where? your analogy is flawed since you are comparing the US to an adult and Iran to a child. Iran is an ancient nation which predates the US by thousands of years. Who are we to lecture them? As for North Korea, there’s only so much we can do with them since they’re already isolated and any military action would likely bring about war and perhaps involve China as well. What more do you think we can or should do with North Korea? They are the real threat. Do you realize that iran wants to use uranium for their main power source? They are trying to back off the oil which is their primary source at this time. It would take a lot of “high grade” uranium to even make 1 nuke and they are getting it from russia. yes, i'm sure they do want nukes as well as the many other nations who have them. we can't stop it w/out an invasion. Yes I know Iran makes threats in regards to Israel. This is nothing new. do you realize Israel has more than enough power to protect themselves? we gave it to them long ago..…attacking Israel would be the demise of Iran and entire middle east at that. They would wipe themselves clear off the map. when you perceive your "defense" to mean telling everyone else in the world what they can and cannot do your idea of "defense" is wrong. Are you for banning guns? if not, why do you NOT have the right to protect yourself from the guns of others? Get my drift? But that entire child putting another in danger analogy…..seriously? dumbing down here a bit…yes I would remove my child from danger. But I still don’t see how that compares to iran and nukes

we just can't go around invading like the world is our playground - we must learn to live with others. we don't even have the resources or manpower for an invasion. Iran will never succeed in crushing israel. if they try anything against our country, it will hit them tenfold. they are not that stupid. they would be slaughtered for trying – end of story. I worry much more about north korea personally. Now they have been working on a missile which could theoretically hit Alaska. they are nuts - but we can't do anything unless they made a move.

BOLDED SECTION 3

This quote has been attributed to multiple sources from multiple right-wing websites. I seriously doubt Tony Blair would say such a thing since it essentially disgraces his own nation’s military. but who knows.

i personally think it would be arrogant to say we are #1..especially after the entire Bush debacle. Proof that we are very very flawed. It’ll take more than misattributed quotes from unknown sources to change my mind on this. Canada and Western Europe all take in large numbers of immigrants so the US isn’t unique. What exactly do you mean by “our strength as a whole”? is it because when you look at the details you find we're not #1 so it's easier to just say "as a whole" since it doesn't require any statistics therefore it can't be refuted? i need specifics. do you mean physical strength? Economic strength? Intellectual or cultural strength? please do tell. b/c we are sadly lacking on many things these days.

BOLDED SECTION 4

Please do not tell me how to think either but in regards to this I was speaking of the statement about his grandmother and where I had seen this information. I do conclude that they were right-wing "nut job" websites and never said there were not any left winged ones out there. Let’s get our facts straight before telling someone how to change their thought process shall we?

But something to think about - Sure there’s crazies on the left.. but they don’t usually get picked as the Vice presidential nominee on the national ticket – hahahahahaha man I crack myself up.

Modified 3 times(s), last time at: 2009/06/13 06:56PM
#16   2009/06/13 06:54PM
Re: Birthers
sarahconnor
image

Quote cats meow: sarahconnor, if i am repeating myself, sorry, may i just say there are a few posters that rock, and you are one of them


well thankyou so much Cats, that means a lot. i admire your ability to be candid and open minded at the same time. if there were more people like you the world would be a nicer place. i don't always get to post on the boards as much as i'd like but when i do, it's always fun! are you on facebook at all? if so you should look me up! email me if you are and i'll give you my real name although my avi on here is really my picture from last year. went through a hat phase!

#17   2009/06/13 09:21PM
Re: Birthers
alwaysEJ
image

lovesit -

I love that quote from Tony Blair. Yes, we are a young nation...& in a few short years we were able to get our sh** together, build the worlds most formidable army, win two world wars, develop a nuclear weapon, send a man to the moon, topple the Soviet Union...we are the most generous nation in the world, sending aid all over the world to fight AIDS & poverty & send more than any other nation whenever there is a natural disaster.

And, you don't hear much about Iran's immigration problem. Apparently, there aren't many people clamoring to get into that country. Maybe the recent 'landslide reelection' of Ahmedenajad is giving potential immigrants second thoughts -

www.reuters.com/article/topNews/idUSEVA14340720090613?sp=true

The gravest mistake Obama can make - well, one of them - is to treat Iran & the Iranian government as if they are legit & have noble intentions.

This is a great article that details 'Iran's Election Charade':

www.humanevents.com/article.php?id=32262


Editing to add - No, Iran's threats to Israel aren't new, however our president is. If I were a rogue leader looking to try something & was irritated that the U.S. was always breathing down my neck...I'd be seriously considering trying something now.

Modified 1 times(s), last time at: 2009/06/13 09:40PM
#18   2009/06/13 09:36PM
Re: Birthers
alwaysEJ
image

Oh wanted to add that this whole 'natural born citizen' thing is likely to be an issue in the future. Not regarding Obama, but Arnold has mentioned in the past that he'd like to change the Constitution so he'd be allowed to run for president. If not him, it's likely there will be someone else who wants to change that rule.

#19   2009/06/14 08:17AM
Re: Birthers
cats meow
image

Quote sarahconnor:
Quote cats meow: sarahconnor, if i am repeating myself, sorry, may i just say there are a few posters that rock, and you are one of them


well thankyou so much Cats, that means a lot. i admire your ability to be candid and open minded at the same time. if there were more people like you the world would be a nicer place. i don't always get to post on the boards as much as i'd like but when i do, it's always fun! are you on facebook at all? if so you should look me up! email me if you are and i'll give you my real name although my avi on here is really my picture from last year. went through a hat phase!


well thank you right back sarahconnor, my niece got me to try facebook, i did not like it at all, LOL, if you would like to e mail me my address is 2katsfornow@gmail.com
ps you look great in a hat, i wish i did, my mom always wore them and she looked great too

#20   2009/06/14 05:03PM
Re: Birthers
lovesit
image

sarahconnor - no no no, I never meant for it to come across as me saying "You don't know? Well you should have known..." I meant for it to come across as "You don't know? Then you need to look it up b/c it changes a whole lot of things"
Sorry, I continuously try to proof read my posts to make sure they can't come across as anything other than my intention, but it still happens.
Lets see...I'll start with my "misattributed quotes," How are tehy misattributd of I cite their author?
Second, about question about if I am for banned guns, etc. No, I am for no gun ban. Why? People kill people, guns don't. So I am for shutting down the person(s) acting dangerously who has the gun , or nuclear weapon, whatever the case may be.
Shutting down those evil men who have nuclear devices, IMO, can hardly be considered "invading like the world is our playground" I see it as "saving our playground." Our problem is not "US" learning how to live with them, the problem is "them" learning how to not kill every one else. Where do we get this authority? The world gave it to us. We earned it. And we will always have it unless we give it away. And if we let evil people hold onto their nuclear "power plants," the world can easily take it away.
As for this quote,"hey are nuts - but we can't do anything unless they made a move."
I guess that is our fundamental difference. I believe we CAN do something about it. I don't believe in waiting for their inevitable strike. Don't worry, though, the president agrees with you, not me.
For this:
Please do not tell me how to think either but in regards to this I was speaking of the statement about his grandmother and where I had seen this information. I do conclude that they were right-wing "nut job" websites and never said there were not any left winged ones out there. Let’s get our facts straight before telling someone how to change their thought process shall we?
I only put that point in there b/c you always bash the right, yet I have never heard you say anything negative bad about the left, and you want fairness don't you?
I won't even try to debate the America is #1 thing. I will never see your view of down talking America, and you will not see my up talking.

So in conclusion, I never meant for it to come across as me telling you how to think about anything. I only meant to keep up the debate. I think I got it all, but if not, I'll talk to you soon!

#21   2009/06/14 05:07PM
Re: Birthers
lovesit
image

Quote alwaysEJ: Oh wanted to add that this whole 'natural born citizen' thing is likely to be an issue in the future. Not regarding Obama, but Arnold has mentioned in the past that he'd like to change the Constitution so he'd be allowed to run for president. If not him, it's likely there will be someone else who wants to change that rule.


I heard that, too. I'm not sure how I would feel about that being changed. On one hand, your experience and education should be whats most important. On the other hand, if you want to rule a nation, you should be born there. Live there the majority of your life, get educated there. How can you rule something you are not extremely intimate with? So I guess I would not be in favor of that changing.

#22   2009/06/14 05:46PM
Re: Birthers
sarahconnor
image

Quote alwaysEJ: lovesit -

I love that quote from Tony Blair. Yes, we are a young nation...& in a few short years we were able to get our sh** together, build the worlds most formidable army, win two world wars, develop a nuclear weapon, send a man to the moon, topple the Soviet Union...we are the most generous nation in the world, sending aid all over the world to fight AIDS & poverty & send more than any other nation whenever there is a natural disaster.

And, you don't hear much about Iran's immigration problem. Apparently, there aren't many people clamoring to get into that country. Maybe the recent 'landslide reelection' of Ahmedenajad is giving potential immigrants second thoughts -

www.reuters.com/article/topNews/idUSEVA14340720090613?sp=true

The gravest mistake Obama can make - well, one of them - is to treat Iran & the Iranian government as if they are legit & have noble intentions.

This is a great article that details 'Iran's Election Charade':

www.humanevents.com/article.php?id=32262


Editing to add - No, Iran's threats to Israel aren't new, however our president is. If I were a rogue leader looking to try something & was irritated that the U.S. was always breathing down my neck...I'd be seriously considering trying something now.




Iran just had an election which the hard-line leader (Ahmedenajad) claimed to have won but others say the election was rigged. The US can't really tell Iran what leader it can or can't have (unless we go in and physically remove him like in Iraq) *but* we can use diplomatic and economic pressure to try and force him out. As for Israel, they've been threatening to bomb Iranian nuclear facilities for about 30 years now. Maybe they will, maybe they won't. Who knows? - same with Iran wanting to wipe out Israel. this is nothing new.

I still seriously have doubts about that quote being from Tony Blair. can you back it up with a citation? Until World War 2 our army was small compared to other major powers. We didn't win two World Wars single-handedly. In fact the first World War we entered three years after it began and the second World War we entered two years after it began. Compare the casualties of the US to Russia, France or Britain and try to say the US won the wars. we also were not the only ones who developed nuclear weapons nor can it be completely attributed to us. it was a team effort.

wiki.answers.com/Q/Who_invented_the_atomic_bomb

During World War II, the United States, with the assistance (collaboration) of physicists, mathematicians, and engineers from the U.S., Britain, Canada and Europe, completed the Manhattan Project to produce the first atomic bomb.

as you can see, we had help. Germany was not far from succeeding themselves...we just did it quicker and smoked japan twice before they had a chance. (with little boy & fat man as they were called) - so war over! we have yet to ever unleash the force of the H bomb. i can only pray we never see such a day.

our country HAS done a lot of good things for other countries but that doesn't mean it comes with stipulations that allow us control. i also wish we could have done better for ourselves during certain tragedies such as with the entire "Katrina" mess. we failed our OWN people with that - what a shame.

I agree we shouldn't pressure Iran into having free and fair elections but there's only so much we can do. so what are your suggestions? Do you suggest a military invasion? Perhaps a tactical air-strike? I know you seem to complain alot but do you have any ideas or details on what we should do? as for "if I were a rogue leader looking to try something" - come on...as if the world is that simple. It's not, it's actually fairly complex, and most of these "rogue leaders" are intelligent politicians (3rd world country or not) who like to play to their base by shifting attention towards a bogeyman like Israel or America. The only exception is Kim Jong-Il in North Korea - he's nuts!!!!!! - but he has China at his back so our hands are tied for now.

Modified 1 times(s), last time at: 2009/06/14 05:50PM
#23   2009/06/14 07:57PM
Re: Birthers
alwaysEJ
image

lovesit - I agree with you regarding talking down America. Yes, we have problems, but it's not as if the fact that we have problems means we have no right to ensure that rogue nations don't acquire nukes. I mean what is that logic..."Since every American doesn't have health insurance, we have no right to tell Iran they cannot build nuclear weapons." That makes no sense.

I have seen the quote attributed to Blair before...regardless of who first said it, it's a powerful sentiment.

I think George W. was right when he called Iran, Iraq, & North Korea an axis of evil. North Korea is led by a madman. North Korea recently vowed to weaponzie their plutonium -

apnews.myway.com/article/20090613/D98PO6T80.html

& has warned of nuclear war -

apnews.myway.com/article/20090614/D98QDSOO0.html.

North Korea recently sentenced two American journalists to 12 years hard labor. They are daring us to do something, make a move...but, China has their back.

I think Kim Jung Il is insane. I think Ahmedenajad has specific goals regarding Israel. I think neither of these men have any 'right' to a nuclear weapon b/c the United States has nuclear weapons. I think North Korea is a more complicated challenge, largely b/c of China. I think the situation with Iran is very clear - Israel should remain our ally, & we should ensure that Israel's enemy, Iran, does not acquire a nuke.

We have many things to deal with here at home in America. It would be great if the rest of the world could tend to their own business. If we do nothing, it is a certainty, IMO, that both Iran & North Korea will acquire & likely use nuclear weapons. I am honestly a big fan of old school CIA missions to take out rogue leaders. I regret to this day that the mission to eliminate Fidel Castro was a failure. I believe the No. 1 responsibility of the federal govt. is to keep Americans safe. Currently the feds are so busy babysitting us all I don't know how they have the time or resources to continue doing what is necessary to keep the world a safe place for freedom & democracy. I mean, what good is it for all Americans to have health insurance if half the world has nuclear warheads pointed at us?



I don't think Katrina has much to do with foreign nations acquiring nukes. It's not as if North Korea or Iran should be given a free pass for a nuke b/c the city of New Orleans fell apart after Katrina. I live in Louisiana. These were the main issues regarding Katrina:

-residents were told to leave, & many didn't, even those who had vehicles or other means of leaving...there are a lot of defiant people in New Orleans who ride out hurricanes & don't listen to warnings, & until Katrina, they'd always been ok
-Ray Nagin, the inept mayor, did not mobilize school buses at his disposal fast enough to organize evacuation of residents who had no other way out
-then governor Kathleen Blanco waited too long to cede power to the federal govt. to take control - the feds cannot intervene in a situation until that state's governor grants permission
-and, I don't for a moment think Bush did everything right, however regardless of who is president, who seriously thinks it is the job of the president of the U.S. to make sure they leave town when they're told to? I mean I would never expect that of anyone, esp. the president (or the governor, for that matter)


The moral of Katrina is this: don't count on the government, state or federal, to rescue you when times are tough.

Modified 2 times(s), last time at: 2009/06/14 08:12PM
#24   2009/06/14 08:18PM
Re: Birthers
alwaysEJ
image

Posse Comitatus . . .that's the name of the 1878 act that prevents the deployment of federal troops on US soil without the permission of a state’s governor

#25   2009/06/14 09:20PM
Re: Birthers
sarahconnor
image

Quote alwaysEJ: lovesit - I agree with you regarding talking down America. Yes, we have problems, but it's not as if the fact that we have problems means we have no right to ensure that rogue nations don't acquire nukes. I mean what is that logic..."Since every American doesn't have health insurance, we have no right to tell Iran they cannot build nuclear weapons." That makes no sense.

I have seen the quote attributed to Blair before...regardless of who first said it, it's a powerful sentiment.

I think George W. was right when he called Iran, Iraq, & North Korea an axis of evil. North Korea is led by a madman. North Korea recently vowed to weaponzie their plutonium -

apnews.myway.com/article/20090613/D98PO6T80.html

& has warned of nuclear war -

apnews.myway.com/article/20090614/D98QDSOO0.html.

North Korea recently sentenced two American journalists to 12 years hard labor. They are daring us to do something, make a move...but, China has their back.

I think Kim Jung Il is insane. I think Ahmedenajad has specific goals regarding Israel. I think neither of these men have any 'right' to a nuclear weapon b/c the United States has nuclear weapons. I think North Korea is a more complicated challenge, largely b/c of China. I think the situation with Iran is very clear - Israel should remain our ally, & we should ensure that Israel's enemy, Iran, does not acquire a nuke.

We have many things to deal with here at home in America. It would be great if the rest of the world could tend to their own business. If we do nothing, it is a certainty, IMO, that both Iran & North Korea will acquire & likely use nuclear weapons. I am honestly a big fan of old school CIA missions to take out rogue leaders. I regret to this day that the mission to eliminate Fidel Castro was a failure. I believe the No. 1 responsibility of the federal govt. is to keep Americans safe. Currently the feds are so busy babysitting us all I don't know how they have the time or resources to continue doing what is necessary to keep the world a safe place for freedom & democracy. I mean, what good is it for all Americans to have health insurance if half the world has nuclear warheads pointed at us?



I don't think Katrina has much to do with foreign nations acquiring nukes. It's not as if North Korea or Iran should be given a free pass for a nuke b/c the city of New Orleans fell apart after Katrina. I live in Louisiana. These were the main issues regarding Katrina:

-residents were told to leave, & many didn't, even those who had vehicles or other means of leaving...there are a lot of defiant people in New Orleans who ride out hurricanes & don't listen to warnings, & until Katrina, they'd always been ok
-Ray Nagin, the inept mayor, did not mobilize school buses at his disposal fast enough to organize evacuation of residents who had no other way out
-then governor Kathleen Blanco waited too long to cede power to the federal govt. to take control - the feds cannot intervene in a situation until that state's governor grants permission
-and, I don't for a moment think Bush did everything right, however regardless of who is president, who seriously thinks it is the job of the president of the U.S. to make sure they leave town when they're told to? I mean I would never expect that of anyone, esp. the president (or the governor, for that matter)


The moral of Katrina is this: don't count on the government, state or federal, to rescue you when times are tough.



i don't have time to address all of this but a few points. I never compared Katrina to foreign nations acquiring nukes...what? where do you derive this from? I said that we have indeed helped out other countries *however* we dropped the ball with Katrina. my point was that i would think looking out for OUR country would be a first priority.

i could also be so blasé to say that those 2 journalists should not have been treading anywhere close to North Korea....i could say the MORAL of that is to not count on the government when you are knowingly in enemy territory. especially a highly dangerous one. however my heart goes out to the families of those journalists...i sure hope we can negotiate a release for them.

But to say the moral of Katrina is to not count on the government when disaster strikes has to be one of the COLDEST statements i've ever heard. yes i'm sure they all learned a hard lesson...many people were dead on the streets....babies died from heat exhaustion - children and adults were crammed in and died in that horrible center riddled with trash and living conditions that were not even tolerable. i hope the thought of that "lesson" pleases you. NO one anticipated Katrina would be that powerful yet it was well known by the government the levees were not as strong as they needed to be. there should have been funding to improve that looooong ago EJ. Evacuations are always recommended for hurricanes. i think you may have noticed that after Katrina, the mere mention of a hurricane threat
sent people on their way OUT in droves. Katrina was a horrible natural disaster. no one said it was the job of the president to make people leave...however it WAS THE JOB of the president to move on that as soon as possible after the fact. Florida had quicker response times and much less damage than what happened with Katrina. so as for those reporters i could use your entire "moral" analogy to fit that situation too but honestly i don't have the heart. even if i think they should have been more careful around North Korea (you could not PAY me enough money to risk going near them) i still hope we can negotiate a release. those reporters have families and 1 has a serious medical condition.

anyway you went into Katrina as if that was some sort of comparison to iran & nukes i made yet nicely deflected from the other statements i mentioned. i guess if you can twist things to focus on something else, why not?

North Korea is out of control. we can't do much right now..like i said in my previous post - b/c of china our hands are tied.

i am not bashing america just b/c i don't agree we are #1. i am just not so arrogant to say we are #1 when clearly we are NOT.

Modified 1 times(s), last time at: 2009/06/14 09:23PM
« 1 2 3 4 5 6 » »| page:

Please register and login to be able to post in this message board.

« Go back to topic list