List of Shows


Tell your friends

TELL YOUR FRIENDS

As the World Turns - MESSAGE BOARDS

Soaps Boards :: As the World Turns Forum :: Did Carly and Lilly REALLY do something wrong?

Please register and login to be able to post in this message board.

Did Carly and Lilly REALLY do something wrong?

Started by Erin at 2008/05/15 12:01AM
Latest post: 2008/05/22 01:41PM, Views: 568, Replies: 39
1 2 3 » »| page:
#1   2008/05/15 12:01AM
Did Carly and Lilly REALLY do something wrong?
Erin
Erin

Come on now---what is jack and holden's deal? Seriously, Carly OFFERED to take the kids' off Holden and Lilly's shoulders, she didn't expect Holden to instantly fall into Lilly's arms, of course, neither did Lilly, even though she hoped for it....Holden could've NOT had dinner with Lilly at all if he "so wasn't ready" , but what did he do, he had dinner, and HE made love to lilly....
So, my question, did Carly and Lilly REALLY do anything wrong???
Yes, Lilly had intentions of making love; but it was afterall, HOlden's decision if he wanted to or not; and I don't think he was forced......Lilly just set up a dinner....that's it....I don't see where it was Jack's busisness to be mad at carly anyway; he's been buttin into her life for the few past weeks....I don't just get them two guys anymore

#2   2008/05/15 04:37AM
Re: Did Carly and Lilly REALLY do something wrong?
Kare Bear
Kare Bear

ITA It seemed like they were making a mountain out of a molehill. They both need to relax. When I heard that Lily was going to get Holden alone, I assumed they were going back to their own house. It was kinda creepy them at the farm where it seems everyone lives instead of their beautiful mansion. Didn't Ethan get big? Seemed like the other day Meg and Paul lost the little toddler and now he is like 4 years old. Wow!

#3   2008/05/15 12:32PM
Re: Did Carly and Lilly REALLY do something wrong?
Tigress1761
Tigress1761

maybe that other kid didn't work out very well, after all, he did get himself locked in that elevator....

I too think Holden and Jack need to get off their 'high horse'. Carly was right to tell Jack how she felt when they made love and he blew her off, its the same thing and he shouldn't be so self righteous all the time.

#4   2008/05/15 02:15PM
Re: Did Carly and Lilly REALLY do something wrong?
soulmates
soulmates

NO!!! Jack, the jerk and Holden the dummy OVEREACTED!!!!

#5   2008/05/15 02:36PM
Re: Did Carly and Lilly REALLY do something wrong?
Uggerly
Uggerly

Quote soulmates: NO!!! Jack, the jerk and Holden the dummy OVEREACTED!!!!


Well Said!!!!

#6   2008/05/15 04:31PM
Re: Did Carly and Lilly REALLY do something wrong?
gymnast14
gymnast14

ITA.Everything Carly or Lily does Holden and Jack act like it's a crime.I mean Carly was just trying to help Lily get some alone time with her husband.It's not like they were ploting a murder or something.I loved when Carly told Jack to arrest her and asked if she'd need her lawyer present.It cracked me up.LOL.Someone needs to put these Snyder men in their place.

#7   2008/05/15 05:58PM
Re: Did Carly and Lilly REALLY do something wrong?
cozzies Biggest fan
cozzies Biggest fan

lILY AND cARLY NEED TO CUT THERE LOSSES and forget the Snyder dorks

#8   2008/05/15 07:07PM
Re: Did Carly and Lilly REALLY do something wrong?
meowbowow
meowbowow

Quote Erin: Come on now---what is jack and holden's deal? Seriously, Carly OFFERED to take the kids' off Holden and Lilly's shoulders, she didn't expect Holden to instantly fall into Lilly's arms, of course, neither did Lilly, even though she hoped for it....Holden could've NOT had dinner with Lilly at all if he "so wasn't ready" , but what did he do, he had dinner, and HE made love to lilly....
So, my question, did Carly and Lilly REALLY do anything wrong???
Yes, Lilly had intentions of making love; but it was afterall, HOlden's decision if he wanted to or not; and I don't think he was forced......Lilly just set up a dinner....that's it....I don't see where it was Jack's busisness to be mad at carly anyway; he's been buttin into her life for the few past weeks....I don't just get them two guys anymore


I said this in yet another one of these threads yesterday that YES, what they did was wrong. They lied and manipulated and both girls know how Jack and Holden feel about that. And Jack wasn't butting in, Carly told him she needed help so he would be away from the farm so Lily/Holden could be alone. She manipulated him yet again, that was WRONG.

#9   2008/05/15 07:09PM
Re: Did Carly and Lilly REALLY do something wrong?
meowbowow
meowbowow

Quote Kare Bear: ITA It seemed like they were making a mountain out of a molehill. They both need to relax. When I heard that Lily was going to get Holden alone, I assumed they were going back to their own house. It was kinda creepy them at the farm where it seems everyone lives instead of their beautiful mansion. Didn't Ethan get big? Seemed like the other day Meg and Paul lost the little toddler and now he is like 4 years old. Wow!


Yeah they turned up the SORAS machine on him!! He was just a baby the last time and now like u said he's probably 3 or 4 yrs old. How ridiculous.

#10   2008/05/15 07:10PM
Re: Did Carly and Lilly REALLY do something wrong?
Angel4Life
Angel4Life

Jack and Holden exhaust me with their high horse standards. They are beginning to be a bore to watch.

#11   2008/05/15 07:21PM
Re: Did Carly and Lilly REALLY do something wrong?
meowbowow
meowbowow

Quote Angel4Life: Jack and Holden exhaust me with their high horse standards. They are beginning to be a bore to watch.


At least they have high standards, unlike their wives!!

#12   2008/05/15 08:09PM
Re: Did Carly and Lilly REALLY do something wrong?
KobeWestonandLexis m
KobeWestonandLexis momma

I just want to know why everyone got so mad b/c Carly and Lily planned something... but remember when Carly, Lily and Holden planned a dinner to reunite Jack and Carly, why was that okay? I'm not diggin this.

#13   2008/05/15 08:20PM
Re: Did Carly and Lilly REALLY do something wrong?
meowbowow
meowbowow

Quote KobeWestonandLexis m: I just want to know why everyone got so mad b/c Carly and Lily planned something... but remember when Carly, Lily and Holden planned a dinner to reunite Jack and Carly, why was that okay? I'm not diggin this.


It wasn't bad b/c they planned something. It was bad b/c they manipulated and lied and that is so not good, anybody should be able to see that!!

#14   2008/05/15 08:44PM
Re: Did Carly and Lilly REALLY do something wrong?
rei1
rei1

Are you kidding me?? A wife that just came home after soul searching realized that she really want's her husband and her family ...Oh God forbid that she will so something to make that happen ..Oh the terror, what an atrosity(sp)

Jack and Holden need to see that this was for the greater good and not a plot to commit a crime for goodness sakes...Heck if it were me in real life I would be flattered and thankful for the time alone with my spouse to re-kindal(sp ) my relationship and I would only have thanks to those who made it happen.

#15   2008/05/15 09:27PM
Re: Did Carly and Lilly REALLY do something wrong?
Uggerly
Uggerly

Quote rei1: Are you kidding me?? A wife that just came home after soul searching realized that she really want's her husband and her family ...Oh God forbid that she will so something to make that happen ..Oh the terror, what an atrosity(sp)

Jack and Holden need to see that this was for the greater good and not a plot to commit a crime for goodness sakes...Heck if it were me in real life I would be flattered and thankful for the time alone with my spouse to re-kindal(sp ) my relationship and I would only have thanks to those who made it happen.


Yes Rei! You are so right! If Holden and Jack have such good and high standards, they should be honoring their women, instead of trying to think of ways to get rid of them! They have familys with these women!!! Come on !!!!If they loved them before, then why are they shamed because they wanted to love them?

1 2 3 » »| page:

Please register and login to be able to post in this message board.

« Go back to topic list