Tell your friends

TELL YOUR FRIENDS

POPULAR SEARCHES

List of Shows


All My Children - MESSAGE BOARDS

Soaps Boards :: All My Children Forum :: MissChef

Please register and login to be able to post in this message board.

MissChef

Started by Feie15 at 2009/10/09 10:17AM
Latest post: 2009/10/12 06:05PM, Views: 566, Replies: 14
page:
#1   2009/10/09 10:17AM
MissChef
Feie15
image

Annie confessed to killing Stuart. What do you think of it? Is she telling the truth?

#2   2009/10/09 10:44AM
Re: MissChef
MissChef
image

Quote Feie15: Annie confessed to killing Stuart. What do you think of it? Is she telling the truth?


Nope. She's lying. (in my opinion) As a mystery writer, you can never accept "the easy way out." She'll say whatever, because she wants freedom, AND she knows what she just said can't be used in court.

#3   2009/10/09 10:50AM
Re: MissChef
MissChef
image

One more thing,

You have to remember, Annie might be "touched" in the head, but she's not stupid. Whoever killed Stuart, she and Emma saw it. If they talk, then Annie loses. That part she told Aidan was true. So, if it's Adam...and Adam gets put away, or Adam realizes Annie knew, but said nothing all so she can continue sponging off him, then he would toss Annie out and she won't have anywhere to live or have no money. My suspects are still:

Zach
Scott
Adam

#4   2009/10/09 03:31PM
Re: MissChef
MRS GEH
image

I noticed that Scott had a weird look and told Adam and Erica that he thinks Annie killed his father after leaving Ryan's place. It is really weird that he did not immediately contact Jesse or go to the police station instead of just bringing it up later at the mansion.

#5   2009/10/09 04:10PM
Re: MissChef
Feie15
image

Quote MissChef: One more thing,

You have to remember, Annie might be "touched" in the head, but she's not stupid. Whoever killed Stuart, she and Emma saw it. If they talk, then Annie loses. That part she told Aidan was true. So, if it's Adam...and Adam gets put away, or Adam realizes Annie knew, but said nothing all so she can continue sponging off him, then he would toss Annie out and she won't have anywhere to live or have no money. My suspects are still:

Zach
Scott
Adam



No. It's not Zack. He was one of the 3 main people in the room. The 3 main people were Kendall, David, and Zack. Therefore, none of them did it. Plus, Zack confessed to Stuart's murder because he thought Kendall did it. Plus, why didn't he shot Adam in the front? It can't be Zack, even if he is leaving.

and Why Scott? I think Scott is giving Annie a hard time because he believes that Annie killed his father, but has no proof. Plus, there is no reason for Annie to protect Scott.

I do think it's Adam.

My top choices are Adam and Gayle.

Gayle could be Annie's cousin. And if Adam knew that Annie was protecting the real killer the whole entire time, she would definitely lose everything. She would lose absolutely everything if Adam knew she was protecting the real killer. Plus, we ALL know how deeply in love Gayle is with Dr. Hayward. She could have killed Stuart, thinking it was Adam so that David could spend more time with his grandchild. She also doesn't want David to go to jail for murder, so she would rather do it in his place. (if that makes sense)

So, either Adam or Gayle.

#6   2009/10/10 05:45PM
Re: MissChef
AidannieFan4Eva
image

[quote]Quote Feie15: [quote]Quote MissChef: One more thing,

You have to remember, Annie might be "touched" in the head, but she's not stupid. Whoever killed Stuart, she and Emma saw it. If they talk, then Annie loses. That part she told Aidan was true. So, if it's Adam...and Adam gets put away, or Adam realizes Annie knew, but said nothing all so she can continue sponging off him, then he would toss Annie out and she won't have anywhere to live or have no money. My suspects are still:

Zach
Scott
Adam

[/quote]

No. It's not Zack. He was one of the 3 main people in the room. The 3 main people were Kendall, David, and Zack. Therefore, none of them did it. Plus, Zack confessed to Stuart's murder because he thought Kendall did it. Plus, why didn't he shot Adam in the front? It can't be Zack, even if he is leaving.

and Why Scott? I think Scott is giving Annie a hard time because he believes that Annie killed his father, but has no proof. Plus, there is no reason for Annie to protect Scott.

I do think it's Adam.

My top choices are Adam and Gayle.

Gayle could be Annie's cousin. And if Adam knew that Annie was protecting the real killer the whole entire time, she would definitely lose everything. She would lose absolutely everything if Adam knew she was protecting the real killer. Plus, we ALL know how deeply in love Gayle is with Dr. Hayward. She could have killed Stuart, thinking it was Adam so that David could spend more time with his grandchild. She also doesn't want David to go to jail for murder, so she would rather do it in his place. (if that makes sense)

So, either Adam or Gayle.[/quote




Good theory!!, I never thought it could of been Gayle!

#7   2009/10/10 07:23PM
Re: MissChef
AJErickson01
image

My guess is Adam.

#8   2009/10/10 10:04PM
Re: MissChef
biffspicey
image

i posted it before, but i still maintain that its greenlee.if it is possible that greenlee is alive,she may have lost her memory.if she is being kept by nurse gayle and david,she may of herd them talk about adam.
thinking only the best of david{for this is all that she now knows}i believe that they both left her to go to the mansion.i think she may of followed them.then she witnessed the confrontation between david and adam.she then mistook stewart for adam, and shot.she wanted to shoot adam,because she loves david, and wanted david happy.
it is simple why annie is not confirming this.she doesnt want anyone to know that greenlee is alive, expecally ryan.
these are not spoilers, just my thoughts.

#9   2009/10/11 12:05PM
Re: MissChef
hiker
image

My vote goes to Adam and that is why Annie is pushing this wedding thing...when he goes away for murder...it will all be hers, at least in her head!!

#10   2009/10/11 12:25PM
Re: MissChef
tami58
image

Quote biffspicey: i posted it before, but i still maintain that its greenlee.if it is possible that greenlee is alive,she may have lost her memory.if she is being kept by nurse gayle and david,she may of herd them talk about adam.
thinking only the best of david{for this is all that she now knows}i believe that they both left her to go to the mansion.i think she may of followed them.then she witnessed the confrontation between david and adam.she then mistook stewart for adam, and shot.she wanted to shoot adam,because she loves david, and wanted david happy.
it is simple why annie is not confirming this.she doesnt want anyone to know that greenlee is alive, expecally ryan.
these are not spoilers, just my thoughts.


WOW!at first glance of your post i thought how lame, and then i quickly went to that's actually a pretty cool theory.kudo's!

#11   2009/10/11 04:21PM
Re: MissChef
MissChef
image

Quote biffspicey: i posted it before, but i still maintain that its greenlee.if it is possible that greenlee is alive,she may have lost her memory.if she is being kept by nurse gayle and david,she may of herd them talk about adam.
thinking only the best of david{for this is all that she now knows}i believe that they both left her to go to the mansion.i think she may of followed them.then she witnessed the confrontation between david and adam.she then mistook stewart for adam, and shot.she wanted to shoot adam,because she loves david, and wanted david happy.
it is simple why annie is not confirming this.she doesnt want anyone to know that greenlee is alive, expecally ryan.
these are not spoilers, just my thoughts.


Well, they could inject Greenlee into this storyline; however, the Stuart murder was probably all pre-thought out prior to the knowledge of Rebecca Budig coming back as Greenlee. (Unless they were going to recast.) But Greenlee has been drugged up for months. If she were to break free; I think shooting Adam or David would be the last thing she'd think of doing. It would make more sense to call Ryan or the police, rather than risk being seen by David only to be captured all over again. I doubt anyone would be in love with the idea of Greenlee being the killer. Also, she remembered Ryan's number because she called him before.

Modified 1 times(s), last time at: 2009/10/11 04:25PM
#12   2009/10/12 12:05PM
Re: MissChef
Feie15
image

Quote MissChef:
Quote biffspicey: i posted it before, but i still maintain that its greenlee.if it is possible that greenlee is alive,she may have lost her memory.if she is being kept by nurse gayle and david,she may of herd them talk about adam.
thinking only the best of david{for this is all that she now knows}i believe that they both left her to go to the mansion.i think she may of followed them.then she witnessed the confrontation between david and adam.she then mistook stewart for adam, and shot.she wanted to shoot adam,because she loves david, and wanted david happy.
it is simple why annie is not confirming this.she doesnt want anyone to know that greenlee is alive, expecally ryan.
these are not spoilers, just my thoughts.


Well, they could inject Greenlee into this storyline; however, the Stuart murder was probably all pre-thought out prior to the knowledge of Rebecca Budig coming back as Greenlee. (Unless they were going to recast.) But Greenlee has been drugged up for months. If she were to break free; I think shooting Adam or David would be the last thing she'd think of doing. It would make more sense to call Ryan or the police, rather than risk being seen by David only to be captured all over again. I doubt anyone would be in love with the idea of Greenlee being the killer. Also, she remembered Ryan's number because she called him before.



EXACTLY! Let's not forget that Greenlee called Ryan, then Gayle took the phone away from her. So, she can't be that drugged up. and if she did break out. I highly doubt she would commit murder.

I think it's Adam, now. I mean, I have thought it was Adam for the longest of time. But Scott's reaction, Today. Now, it is definitely Adam. Not Gayle, Greenlee, Madison. Scott's behavior proves Adam is the killer.

#13   2009/10/12 05:25PM
Re: MissChef
MissChef
image

Feie,

Didn't I tell you that Emma was afraid of Adam? See...nobody listens to me. LOL

But I agree...it's either Adam or Scott. Anybody else, I think Scott would have called the police to get justice for his dad.

#14   2009/10/12 05:53PM
Re: MissChef
soapfan08
image

Remembring all the tunnels and secret rooms in the Chandler manson, make me think perhaps Stuarts wife, or one of the past Chandler children wanted Adam dead and murdered Stuart instead. Mystery writer never go with the usual suspects. But then again this is a soap on the move so anything can happen.

#15   2009/10/12 06:05PM
Re: MissChef
MRS GEH
image

Quote MissChef: Feie,

Didn't I tell you that Emma was afraid of Adam? See...nobody listens to me. LOL

But I agree...it's either Adam or Scott. Anybody else, I think Scott would have called the police to get justice for his dad.



I remember MissChef mentioning that Emma appeared to be afraid of Adam. Wow, if Adam really did this how are they going to handle it?? Will he end up at Oak Haven after suffering a breakdown or just stay at the mansion and marry wacko Annie (I hope not!)?????

page:

Please register and login to be able to post in this message board.

« Go back to topic list