All My Children - MESSAGE BOARDS

that was killed. I am new here - hi everyone - had to give my opinion. I guess I just wanted it documented because if I am right I can say "that's what I thought from the beginning" and people can't say "yea sure it was"!

Anyway I think it's Adam that was really killed and the person everyone thinks is Adam is really Stewart. So much of Stewart comes out in this "Adam" and wouldn't it be interesting if Scott and his Dad turned out to be interested in the same person - Annie! When the twin brother died he said I deserved this for all I've done to all of you (or something like that). I think Annie knows this and is drugging Stewart. And that this is the secret that Emma knows, and this is the secret that Annie is protecting because she wants "Adam's" money and power.

Just my opinion - what do you think?

It's definitely Stewart that was murdered. Adam was so drugged up by David he thought he was shooting himself. That's why he was saying things as he was falling down after being shot. Adam shot Stewart and thats what Emma saw.
Annie needs Adam's help to get Emma back so she is protecting him. Please see posts that were previously discussed about this topic.

Like I said - just my opinion - and with this show?? we won't know "WHO DEFINITELY SHOW WHOMEVER" until we know! I have read the other posts and - everyone is entitled to their opinion. I've watched this show from the beginning - day one - and still think there is some merit to my theory - just thought I'd share. You don't have to agree, but no one is right or wrong until we know! Hey, and it's the soaps so even then - we don't know!

Welcome Soapwatcher1947. Don't think in what you're saying is way out there cause there has been a couple of other posts about people saying they think maybe it could be Adam that died. You could be on to something. It's an idea being thrown around so you could be correct

Hey!!!that's what I think tooo!!!that would be an awesome story line...Adam is really Stewart and Stewart was Adam...yes!!! It's about time someone thinks like I do..and they said "I was crazy"...Crazy like a Fox...haha

I agree! Let's find out already

Funny you should say this. I had a fleeting though while watching the show the other day and thought that there was a bit of Stewart in there as well and had thought that maybe it really was Adam that was shot. Yes what he said as he died was more of an Adam thought than a Stewart because everyone loved Stewart and he had no problems with people like Adam did. Good point there.Hmmm leaves a lot to the imagination doesn't it?

I AGREE ADAM SHOT STUART... THAT'S WHO ANNIE IS PROTECTING
ADAM, EMMA SAW IT, THAT'S THE SECRET EMMA & ANNIE IS SHARING.

Okay, Adam shot Stewart and Adam goes to jail and that is why Adam is not moving to CA. Simple enough, huh????

Not sure if I buy this theory, because Stuart isn't the type of person to lie and let people believe he's dead (especially his wife and son). However, I've been puzzled by those dying words since it was revealed that Adam was alive and for the life of me can't figure out how they could possibly relate to Stuart.

It quite possibly could be Adam who accidentally killed Stuart, and in his drug haze may have hallucinated that it was he who was dying. But then I wonder why on earth Annie would throw her own daughter under the bus in order to protect Adam. That doesn't make sense either.

One thing I noticed last week is they showed Emma remembering a hand holding a gun. The arm was wearing a long black sleeve, and the hand appeared to belong to either a large-handed beginning-to-show-age woman or a small-handed man. Rewatching the episode where Stuart is killed, there were quite a few people wearing long-sleeved black shirts or jackets, but only two people have hands that come close to resembling the hand Emma remembered -- Liza and David.

So who knows! Just wish they'd get to it already. This whole thing with Kendall, Erica and Ryan is wearing really thin.